·

·
Showing posts with label Garbage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Garbage. Show all posts

Phatic (Dys)functions

Genosko, Gary 2000. Phatic (Dys)functions: The Shifting Contour of the TV Screen. Semiotics Institute Online lecture.

This lecture is grounded in a debate in communication theory about the functionality of phatic communication [...] (Genosko 2000)
When and where was this debate held?
The lesson of this debate, which shows the inherent dysfunctionality of the concept, is then applied to a further dimension of contact – that is, tactility – and its fortunes in media studies of television, with particular attention to screens themselves. (Genosko 2000)
Huh? Is it dysfunctional because "the phatic function of speech" etymologically amounts to "the speech function of speech"? Because in that case one can refer to precedents in Roman Jakobson's thinking that moot this putative dysfunction. I also have an inkling that this emphasis on "tactility" takes "contact" to mean actual physical bodily touch instead of communicative contact. That is not at all what most theorists and researchers mean by "phatic". Only other case I'm currently aware of that takes it so literally is the glue manufacturer who thought the emphasis on contact could make "Super Phatic'" a good name for a specialty glue.
Again, the consequences of contact with the tactile medium of tv, while full of potential for valorizing in various ways synesthetic experience, tend toward dystopic elaborations in theory as well as in various kinds of popular practices (pop music and film). (Genosko 2000)
I was not aware that TV connects viewers with the visual conten via the sense of touch. In fact it makes very little sense.
Russian linguist Roman Jakobson (“Closing Statement” 1960) derived the Phatic function of his poetic model of communication from Malinowski’s concept of “phatic communion,” the use of language to maintain a social relation through ritualized formulas such as greetings, chit-chat about the weather. (Genosko 2000)
As logical as it is, I suspect that it's not true. I'm suspect that he took the term and the meaning with it's modifications from David Abercrombie, and pretty sure that he added the part about holding attention from Hobart Mowrer and some technical aspects of channel regulation from Gregory Bateson. There is very little left of Malinowski's conception of phatic communion in Jakobson's formulation of the phatic function.
If Jakobson advances this social function, it is by inclusion of the means of discontinuing communication rather than simply prolonging it (including confirmation of the interlocutor’s attention). (Genosko 2000)
As I just explained, Mowrer (1949) and Bateson (1951).
The “mere purport,” as Jakobson puts it, of prolonging communicative contact suggests the emptiness of such contact; the example from Dorothy Parker is illustrative: ‘Well, here we are’, he said. ‘Here we are’, she said, ‘Aren’t we?’ ‘I should say we are’, he said. (Genosko 2000)
Not emptiness but awkwardness. The characters in Parker's short story are newlyweds traveling by train to New York City for the first night of their honeymoon. There are reasons for awkwardness in that particular example. Their dialogue is characterized by semantic emptiness (or referential irrelevance). Their relationship (contact) itself is not empty just because they are nervous.
This not only makes the function susceptible to atrophy in which there is “constant contact without a message,” [Umberto Eco] but in addition suggests that the emptiness of contact has a propitious technical function as a test of the system itself: “Hello, do you hear me?” (Genosko 2000)
Unless there are phatic technologies that make the contact an auxiliary function, there is no contact without a message. The latter part takes one of Jakobson's illustrations way too seriously. My argument is that this is a linguistic reformulation of Bateson's "signals asking for signals to be repeated" (Bateson 1951: 209). This is just one type of metacommunicative signals. It's not the essence of phatics as such.
The Phatic function shares a great deal with the Metalingual function. (Genosko 2000)
This is actually pretty incisive. Both phatic and metalingual function have their beginnings in Bateson's theory of metacommunication, which itself was divided into communication about code (metalingual function) and communication about relationship (phatic function).
Jean Baudrillard has advanced a telling critique of the Phatic function as a “simulation pact” based on “tele-phasis”(Seduction, 163-66). Baudrillard writes: “The phatic function of language, used to establish contact and sustain speech’s formal dimension: this function first isolated and described by Malinowski with reference to the Melanesians, then by Jakobson in his grid of language’s functions, becomes hypertrophied in the tele-dimension of the communications networks. Contact for contact’s sake becomes the empty form with which language seduces itself when it no longer has anything to say.” (Genosko 2000)
I often have a nagging feeling that Baudrillard doesn't really know what he's going on about. Excuse me, Baudrillard's critique, while breaking and tearing through the anatomy of communication, prefaces the postmodern performance of contact with an articulation of the struggle to assure substance in an otherwise rigidly disciplined authority in the rhetorical biomechanic of that particular sanguine system of functions that populist linguistics vexes as a necessary and apparent innovation. Jakobson's scheme of language functions is a schematic, not a grid. What he seems to say is that the scheme of language functions doesn't really work well when applied on televised communication. That makes perfect sense, for it was meant for speech analysis, not makeshift culturology. Contact for sake of contact is as empty as when people who are otherwise strangers exchange formulaic expressions in order to get to know each other and establish some sort of relationship. If that is empty then so be it. Human relations are empty then. But what really irks me is the phrase "with which language seduces itself". Not only is language, that system of signs humans use, given agency and removed from the users of language, by making it reflexive (seduces itself) it also removes language from those whom it is used on. In other words, all human intervention is removed from language and the abstract system takes on a life of its own in some abstract universe that only Baudrillard and other French critics have privileged access to comment upon. For everyone else language is a tool, for them it is a monster.
This is what Eco calls “sports chatter” – vapid phatic communication in which one may be totally immersed but with negative consequences. (Genosko 2000)
Vapid? Define: offering nothing that is stimulating or challenging. Vapid! Hey! That's the thing what this lecture is.
In Seduction Baudrillard has much to say about the phatic function as it hypertrophies in the cold universe of information systems. The zero degree of contact in the tele-dimension: tele-phasis. (Genosko 2000)
Information systems are cold only if you go looking for human contact where there absolutely is none. Information systems are information systems, not social systems. Tele-phasis is what? Tele-speech?
By the time Jakobson revisited the concept he had lost its original symbolic sense in Malinowski, Baudrillard maintains. That is, it no longer involved incessant and metabolic ceremonial challenges and ritual exchanges: “Language has no need for ‘contact’: it is we who need communication to have a specific ‘contact’ function, precisely because it is eluding us.” (Genosko 2000)
By the time Jakobson revisited the concept, phatic communion had devalued in anthropological review into "talk for the sake of talk". Jakobson gave it an inalienable place in the scheme of language functions, acknowledging that speech always involves some form of social contact, be it through speech or writing, it is always another person who receives and decodes it. Language itself, of course, has no need for anything. It has no agency of its own, at least no more than any other human invented tool has. By emphasizing elusiveness and emptyness I get that Baudrillard is trying to be edgy, but it comes across as poignantly polemical over basically nothing of substance.
The phatic function “analytically restores” what is missing in communication, far, far removed from the “frayed spaces” of genuine interpersonal exchange in the pulsing (beyond meaning) “tele space” of networked terminals at the ends of which classical assumptions about “inter-individual logic” no longer make sense. (Genosko 2000)
"What the fuck did you just fucking say about me, you little bitch?" communication systems respond "I'll have you know I graduated top of my class in the Navy Seals, and I've been involved in numerous secred raids on Al-Quaeda, and I have over 300 confirmed kills."
So, Phatic communication is primarily (dys)functional; to put it another way, this function is almost immediately tied to its dysfunction: it holds open the channel but in so doing puts genuine communication at risk. (Genosko 2000)
Thus far I've seen nothing but rhetoric and French demagoguery to substantiate this claim. In actuality the phatic function holds open the channel in order that genuine communication can occur. Genuine communication is unimaginable without some social lubricate to releave the tension of strangeness when confronting a stranger. The phatic function of speech in fact enables communication. The only way it can become dysfunctional is when it stops functioning (when people are unable to engage in it for whatever reason, perhaps due to not knowing the local language and customs) or when it is viewed, on the theoretical plane, as a creature on its own unhinged from the system of communication it is actually a part of. That is, phatic communication is dysfunctional only when it is reduced to being phatic only, which is theoretically possible but practically... unpractical.
One of the most enduring figures in ongoing efforts to decode the experience of television is the medium’s tactility. Whether it is a trope of stickiness, massage, jolts and other body blows, or the effects of a protruding gaze of an eye-window-frame-potato processing, pablum dispensing machine, seems moot. (Genosko 2000)
Words are plaything which which I juggle universes from reality to unreality and back without a connexion to coöperation that complexifies the content in contractable contexts full of convexities and concaves of concatenation. This lecture is potatoe and I refuse to continue reading it.

The Nonverbal Communication Reader

Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.) 2008. The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press.

The use of smell as a communication code is called olfactics. This code also includes olfactic elements that are hard to manage or control, such as bodily hormones. (Guerrero & Hecht 2008: 46)
Olfactics is "The study of smells and how they are perceived." I see no point in perpetuating this emic field, as most emic fields (e.g. kinesics, proxemics, tactilesics) are stillborns. This, turns out, is not an exception. Cf. Piesse, Charles Henry 1887. Olfactics and the Physical Senses. London: Piesse and Lubin.
Hesitancies and other types of pauses can also affect how you are perceived (your competence and credibility, for example) as well as how your words are interpreted. Take the following phrase: Woman without her man is helpless. If you believe in equality of the sexes, you probably didn't like the "sound" of that statement. Now read the same statement with pauses included: Woman: without her, man is helpless. The sentence now has a completely different meaning. (Guerrero & Hecht 2008: 46)
Yeah, now it demeans men instead of women.
Finally, regulators help you structure and manage interaction. You might lean forward and put your hands out when you are interrupting or want a chance to speak. Similarly, if you are in a student role, you might raise your hand if you want to speak. If you are the teacher or group leader, you might point at people to let them know it is okay for them to take a speaking turn. Regulators such as these help keep conversations running smoothly and efficiently. (Guerrero & Hecht 2008: 103-104)
That is an upbeat utilitarian view of regulators. Regulators can also be disruptive, aggressive, and controlling (dominating).
The contact codes include both proxemics and haptics. Proxemics is concerned with the perception and use of space. This includes how space is organized, how territory is used and defended, and how distance is maintained and altered between and among people. Haptics refers to touch behavior, which is sometimes called tactile communication.
The use of space involves the complicated balancing of affiliative and privacy needs. People have the need to affiliate or be in contact with other people. Very few people can survive in isolation for extended periods of time. People offer us the stimulation, support, and contact needed for psychological and physical health. On the other hand, people also need privacy. People prefer to have space around them and to be alone for certain periods of time. (Guerrero & Hecht 2008: 182)
Western people do.

Guerrero, Laura K., Michael L. Hecht and Jospeh A. DeVito 2008. Perspectives on Defining and Understanding Nonverbal Communication. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 3-20.

Even when communicating via e-mail, people often insert nonverbal forms of communication, such as smiley faces bold letters, and exaggerated punctiation (!!!!!!!). (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 3-4)
These are not exactly "nonverbal", as they belong to the expressive means of verbal language. These are in effect paralinguistic forms of communication.
However, there are times when the nonverbal messages are more influential than verbal messages. Nonverbal messages are particularly important when expressing emotion, forming impressions, and communicating relational messages, such as intimacy and dominance (Noller 1984; Patterson, 1983). (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 5)
Emotive conative and phatic (metacommunicative, μ-) functions. Intimacy and dominance boil down to sexuality and aggression.
Nonverbal communication includes all the messages other than words that people exchange in interactive contexts. However, this does not mean that everything other than words counts as nonverbal communication; the nonverbal behavior must be a message. To qualify as a message, a behavior typically must be sent with intent/or it must typically be interpreted by others as meaning something. In other words, it must have a social meaning. For example, if you vary your voice tone to make it clear that you are being sarcastic, you have communicated with intent. If you are nervous when you give a public speech, and your hands and voice shake a little bit, you are not intentionally communicating your nervousness. Nonetheless, the audience is likely to attoch a meaning to (and therefore to interpret) your shaking hands and voice as signs of nervousness. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 5-6)
A somewhat useless distinction, because nonverbal communication may occur without conscious awareness, making the question of intent superfluous.
As Frey, Botan, Friedman, and Kreps (1991) stated, "Communication is the management of messages for the purpose of creating meaning. That is, communication occurs whenever a person attempts to send a message or whenever a person perceives and assigns meaning to behavior" (p. 28). This doesn't mean, however, that all behaviors constitute communicative messages (Bavelas, 1991). Messages stand for something other than themselves. Behavior, in contrast, stands for itself. It just is. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 6)
So intrinsically coded nonverbal communication does not exist?
We define the nonverbal codes by the means of expression we use. Each code is communicated by a different nonverbal channel, such as your body, the environment, or the space between people. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 9)
This could be called "the channel reliance fallacy", a vestige of early communication theory that investigated the technical aspects of communication. Identifying codes with channels makes the notion of code moot. It is more likely that nonverbal codes transcend specific channels, or that any given channel may demonstrate several codes.
Sending Relational Messages. You use nonverbal behaviors to tell others how you feel about them. You alse evaluate the nonverbal communication of others to try to figure out how they feel about you. Many different positive relational messages are communicated nonverbally. You can show others that you like them, are similar to them, and trust them. You can also use nonverbal communication to help define a relationship as formal or informal, and as task related or socially oriented (Burgoon et al., 1996). (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 11)
This is called metacommunication. The bold part concerns phatic communion, especially in the dimension of anxiety or stress (due to strangers or threatening behaviour). Otherwise it seems that this specific line of thought originates from Goffman, who expanded metacommunication to concerns of the social organization of gatherings, e.g. the definition of the situation (formal, informal, focused, unfocused).
The opposite of immediacy is nonimmediacy. Nonimmediacy functions to create distance and cut off communication. Maintaining large distances, leaning and looking away from someone, and engaging in defensive posturing, such as hugging your arms around your body, signal that you are unavailable for communication and possibly dislike someone. Whether nonverbal behaviors are used to signal affiliation or distance, they help us communicate our feelings without necessarily having to verbalize them. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 12)
This is a peaseism. Hugging your arms around your body does not mean what Pease thought it meant. Tsk, tsk, perpetuating myths.
Sending Messages of Power and Persuasion. Nonverbal messages exercise social control (Patterson, 1983). Such messages can beused to control people and events, to establish or exert power, or to dominate others. Think of the strong leaders you know. They probably have a distinctive nonverbal style. Powerful people touch others more thhan they are touched. They look at others less than they are looked at (except when they use gaze to "stare someone down") and they have control over time and territory. For example, presidents of large corporations have the power to start and stop meetings and to arrive late. They can also control whether meetings are held and who is allowed to attend particular meetings. Powerful people also take up more space than less powerful people, and environments can be used to control people by structuring interaction. Take a look at your classroom. If it is like most others, the teacher will have a large share of the space to move around in, and the chairs will be arranged so that the students pay attention to the teacher and not to each other. Desks also prevent students from moving around and taking up too much space. Space is used similarly in business settings, with executives having large private offices protected by territorial markers (such as a secretary who controls who enters), and subordinates working side by side or in small cubbyholes. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 14)
More hope and fanfare than actual results. The part about touching is false, if I remember correctly. Not to mention culturally conditioned. It's a powerful idea, the nonverbal communication of power, but confused too much with dominance.
Whether you are trying to create a positive first impression, signal that you are attracted to someone, or get someone to do something for you, nonverbal communication does not occur in vacuum. As our definition of nonverbal communication suggests, nonverbal messages are exchanged within an intercational context. This context includes cultural, relational, and situational elements. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 15)
Nonverbal communication also occurs outside of interactional contexts. There can be nonverbal communication without mutual awareness and perception.
The important point here is that, like verbal communication, nonverbal communication should be viewed as a "cultural event." Interestingly enough, a booklet was distributed to all 37,000 United States volunteers working the Pan American Games to warn them that nonverbal messages are evaluated differently across cultures:
Realize that gestures can be significant. Hand motions which are innocent in one culture may be offensive in another. Keep your hands relatively still and refrain from pointing - instead use wide arm motions, turning your head in the desired direction. Avoid scratching your nose, indicating the number two by holding up two fingers, or making the thumbs up or the "O.K." sign. (Sports Illustrated, Augist, 1987, p. 16)
Although virtually all cultures interpret some nonverbal behaviors similarly (such as smiling), all cultures also differ from one another in interpreting other nonverbal messages. The message is clear. When you are in a different culture, find out the nonverbal rules that influence how your behavior will be interpreted. (Guerrero, Hecht & DeVito 2008: 15)
Nah, even smiling is not universal. A smile means different things for Russians and Americans. Display Rules are serious business.

Spitzberg, Brian H. 2008. Perspectives on Nonverbal Communication Skills. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 21-26.

Certainly, the search for these skills is an important one. An examination of over 300 studies and reviews conducted by Spitzberg and Cupach (1988, 2002) indicate that people who are less socially skilled are likely to be lower in self-esteem, academic success, and occupational success; and higher in levels of loneliness, shyness, depression, mental illness, marital distress, hypertension, stress, and anxiety. Psychological problems such as depression, social anxiety, schizophrenia, eating disorders, personality disorder, and mental health are all deeply affected by the interpersonal skills through which social life is conducted (Segrin, 2001). (Spitzberg 2008: 22)
Sounds like Jurgen Ruesch. Although it also sounds like a marketing ploy for social skills training.
Dillard (2002) examined the results of sixteen studies of social skills. By looking at the results of several different studies, they were able to make more reliable and confident conclusions about which behaviors are most consistently perceived to be skillful or competent. Out of twelve behaviors studied, nine were nonverbal: response latency (the average or total amount of time it takes after one person stops talking before the other person begins talking), eye gaze (the average or total amount of time a conversant spends looking in the general region of the other person's face), eye contact (the average or total amount of time spent looking directly at the other person's eyes), smiles (the frequency or total number of smiles in a conversation), head movements (generally, the number of head nods indicating understanding, agreement, or reinforcement), adaptors (e.g., finger-tapping, hair-twirling, or ring-twisting behaviors), volume (the average loudness of talk), vocal variety (the level of expressiveness in tone, pitch, pace, and other vocal qualities), and talk time (either the total amount of time a person spends talking or the average duration of speaking turns). All of these behaviors were related to perceptions of subject skillfulness; generally speaking, the more of each of these behaviors a person displayed, the more competent the person was perceived to be. The exception was the category of adaptors, such that the fewer adoptors displayed, the more competent the person was considered to be. Similar results have been found in other studies, for behaviors such as gestures, open or facing body orientation, visual attention, body recline, dress, time talked, and smiles (Berry & Hansen, 2000; Gifford, Ng, & Wilkinson, 1985). (Spitzberg 2008: 22)
The problem here is that most sources were published in the 1980s, when the means of measurements weren't exactly ideal. It also coincides with the discourse of positive thinking and "confidence solves everything" type of attitude.
Extensive analyses indicated that these behaviors can be characterized according to four fundamental dimensions: coordination, attentiveness, composure, and expressiveness. Coordination concerns how well verbal speaking turns are managed, maintaining topical flow, and handling the initiation and termination of conversations. This dimension consists of behaviors such as "initiation of new topics," "maintenance of topics and follow-up comments," "use of time relative to partner," and "speaker fluency." Attentiveness represents the extent to which someone shows attention to, concern for, and interest in the other person in the conversation. It is exemplified by behaviors such as "use of eye contact," "nodding of head in response to partner's statements," "lean toward partner," and "speaking about self" and about "partner." Composure involves not only anxiety and nervousness, but also level of confidence and assertiveness. Composure (or lack thereof) is most clearly indicated by behaviors such as "vocal confidence," "shaking or nervous twitches," "posture," and "fidgeting." Finally, expressiveness concerns the level of animation and activity in the conversation and is identified by behavior such as "smiling and/or laughing," "use of gestures," "facias expressiveness," "volume," "vocal variety," and "speaking rate." (Spitzberg 2008: 24)
A definition of expressiveness could go a long way towards improving the so-called emotive function.
Some skills will be more important for creating an impression of power or status (e.g., raised eyebrows, closer interpersonal distance; Hall, coats & LeBeau, 2005), whereas others are more closely related to avoiding the impression of being anxious (e.g., lack of fidgeting, polite smiles; Heerey & Kring, 2007). (Spitzberg 2008: 24-25)
Haha, what?

Hecht, Michael L. and Laura K. Guerrero 2008. Perspectives on Nonverbal Research Methods. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 27-43.

Most research questions fall under one of the following types: (1) finding descriptive categories; (2) finding relationships between things; (3) finding differences in one thing based on another thing. Examples for each type of question are provided next.
  1. Describe a type of nonverbal behavior. For example, what rae the different styles of walking?
    Planalp (see article 43) was interested in describing the various ways that emotion is expressed. Planalp and her colleagues had people fill out questionnaires when they noticed that someone they knew was feeling an emotion. The questionnaire asked them to describe "how they could tell" that the person was experiencing an emotion. The responses to this question were then categorized into various types of emotional cues, such as vocal cues, facial cues, and physiological cues.
  2. Describe how one type of nonverbal behavior is related to another type of nonverbal behavior or to a perception or outcome. For example, do we touch more if eye contact increases? How do people perceive individuals who use very high levels of touch and eye contact?
    Kraut and Johnston (article 15) describe how the presence of others influences smiling. They found that in four situations, people smile more when others are around than when they are alone and tend to use smiling to express friendliness rather than inner happiness.
  3. Describe how nonverbal behavior differs based on the type of person, group, relationship, or situation. For example, do children behave differently than adults? Do people from different cultures display different amounts of touch? Do people show different levels of eye gaze when with friends as compared to strangers? Do people behave differently in various types of environments (e.g., in bright orange vs. soft pink rooms)?
    Guerrero and Andersen (article 25) examined two of these types of questions. They observed the touch behavior of heterosexual romantic couples in movie theater and zoo lines. They found that men tended to initiate touch in casual dating relationships, whereas women tended to initiate touch in married relationships. They also found that couples who were seriously dating touched more than couples who were casually dating or married. Thus, this study answers questions regarding possible differences due to a personal attribute (female vs. male) and the relationships (casually dating vs. seriously dating vs. married).
Research questions, such as those described above, are used when a researcher does not want to limit what is looked at/or if there is not enough information to make a specific prediction (e.g., when examining a new area of research). It is a good idea to ask a research question if a researcher wants to describe an important context for nonverbal behaviors (e.g., airports where terrorists might be present), or if there hasn't been very much previous research on a particular topic, or if the past research on an issue has been inconsistent or contradictory. (Hecht & Guerrero 2008: 29-30)
This reminds me of a suggestion in a how-to-do-easy-research type of book. It was advised to not try to be original but to take something that has already been studied and add a variable.
You could also record the interactions on DVD so you could check for observable differences in people's behavior when they were lying versus the truth. (Hecht & Guerrero 2008: 35)
DVD? Oh, 2008.
Regardless of whether the study uses an experiment or an observation, the researcher will have to record nonverbal communication or people's reactions to nonverbal behavior. Recording describes nonverbal communication. When a researcher relates this description to descriptions of other nonverbal behavior, emotions, attitudes, people, or situations, we can try to predict or explain nonverbal communication. The five most common methods of recording used in nonverbal research are surveys, coding systems, field notes, diaries, and measures of physiological response. (Hecht & Guerrero 2008: 37)
Recording more like scribes than describes nonverbal communication. Describing implies linguistic operations foreign to devices that record.
Field Notes. A third recording method is called field notes. Field notes may use one of the previous systems or may just involve going into a setting and writing down descriptions of the observations. It is usually best to record the notes while making the obvervation. If this interferes with the situation (for example, writing notes at a party), then the researcher will record the observations as soon afterward as they can. Some observers will even retreat to the bathroom to record notes as soon as possible! These notes will not be as clear or as descriptive as data gathered by the previous two systems, but they leave the researcher free to observe anything that occurs rather than just what is in the recoding system. Sometimes audiotape recorders are used for field notes. At times researchers use digital cameras or cell phones to record events. These recordings can later be coded using one of the systems above, and/or the researchers can use open-ended notes to describe the behaviors they have recorded. (Hecht & Guerrero 2008: 40)
Edward T. Hall, for example, carried a spy camera with him to take of pictures of people's proxemic behaviour in public places.

Myers, Philip N., Jr., and Frank A. Biocca 2008[1992]. The Effect of Television Advertising and Programming on Body Image Distortions in Young Women. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 50-58.

Silverstein et al. (1986) examined the body representations and the preoccupation with thinness in various media: (a) television shows and their characters; (b) magazine advertisements and articles dealing with body shape and size, dieting, food and drink, or cooking; (c) photographs of women in two women's magazines; and (d) photographs of female movie stars. (Myers & Biocca 2008[1992]: 51)
Body representations vs. body articulations?
Four hundred and fortyzsix female senior high school students were interviewed, and tricep skinfold measurements were taken to determine their body fat levels. (Myers & Biocca 2008[1992]: 54)
An archaic means to measure body fat (in 1967).
Medical records from more than a century ago show that successful weight loss brought a great deal of self-esteem and satisfaction to patients (Casper, 1983). Weight loss, in an attempt to achieve the ideal body image, is more than inches and pounds to the woman with an eating disorder - it becomes a way of life. Starvation, binge eating, and purging become intensely emotional experiences. As the illness progresses and weight continues to decrease, "anorexics become convinced that they are special and different, that being so thin makes them worthwhile, significant, extra-ordinary, eccentric, or outstanding; each one has a private word to describe the states of superiority she strives for" (Bruch, 1978, p. 79). (Myers & Biocca 2008[1992]: 55)
Isn't this what most people desire? Or maybe I'm just ill. In any case, I'd like to know more about these private words. The quote here is immediately followed with this: "Then they feel they are no longer able to communicate with ordinary people, who won't understand. [br] Such increasing isolation has probably the most [pg 75] corroding effect on the long-range tragic development. Deprived of all corrective experiences, in particular the contact with their own gae group during the important period of adolescent development, they become completely self-absorbed, ruminating only about weight and food. Their thinking and goals become bizarre, and they construct weird ideas about what happens to food." (Bruch 2001[1978]: 74-75) No illustrations of these private words are given and the style seems to be very hyperbolic.

Kurzban, Robert & Jason Weeden 2008[2005]. HurryDate: Mate Preferences in Action. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 59-68.

Overall, the results suggest that people tend to prefer mates who have observable characteristics that are valued by most people rather than mates who are similar to themselves. Choices about who was desirable to date were based more on physical attributes such as attractiveness, weight, height, and age rather than attributes such as education, religion, attitudes toward sex, number of children one has, or the desire to have children in the future. Specifically, women tended to choose men who had attractive faces, were tall, and whose weight was in proportion to their heigh. Men tended to choose women who had a low BMI, were younger and had an attractive face, with weight-to-height ratio being the most important determinant for whether a woman was given a "yes." To a lesser degree, people were likely to choose partners who were similar to them in terms of height and race. (Kurzban & Weeden 2008[2005]: 62)
Both genders seem to be interested in people who have a healthy-looking height-to-weight ratio.
HurryDate events provide strong evidence for the importance of generally agreed-upon mate values as opposed to mate values driven by assortative or other attribute-matching trends, and these generally agreed-upon mate values derive almost exclusively from observable attributes, such as physical attractiveness, BMI, height, age, and race. HurryDate participants are given three minutes in which to make their judgments, but they mostly could be made in three seconds. (Kurzban & Weeden 2008[2005]: 63)
E.g. people are not drawn to people who are similar or dissimilar to them, but rather towards a common image of attractiveness.
When compared directly, the size of the correlations between attractiveness ratings and desirability for men and women are of similar magnitudes. The crucial difference is that we were able to include BMI, which is a powerful determinant of women's bodily attractiveness, but not for men's - for men, factors such as waist-to-chest ratio play a much stronger role than BMI does (Maisey, Vale, Cornelissen, & Tovee, 1999). (Kurzban & Weeden 2008[2005]: 63)
I recall an episode (possibly the only one I've ever seen) of some Estonian dating show, in which Gabriel Kubjas ("Farmi Gabriel") was a contestant. Despite being in a good shape, moderately handsome and juggling with fire, he got turned down by all but a single heavier Russian woman. When asked why 20 girls turned him down, one actually said something that his chest looks too big. He was wearing a fancy blouse that made his chest look double the size of his waist. He overdid it by so large a margin that he came across as grotesque.

Kaiser, Susan B. 2008[1997]. Women's Appearance and Clothing within Organizations. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 74-81.

Although men have a fairly established code of business attire and are likely to be viewed as both attractive and competent if they follow this code, women seem to be forced in some organizational contexts to make a choice between aesthetics and creativity versus competence. (Kaiser 2008[1997]: 76-77)
I'm more interested in why there's this strict dressing code for men in the first place.

Frank, Mark G. and Thomas Gilovich 2008[1988]. Black Uniforms and Aggression in Professional Sports. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 82-85.

A convenient feature of the traditional American Western films was the ease with which the viewer could distinguish the good guys from the bad guys: The bad guys wore the black hats. Of course, film directors did not invent this connection between black and evil, but built upon an existing association that extends deep into our culture and language. When a terrible thing happens on a given day, we refer to it as a "black day," as when the Depression was ushered in by the infamous "Black Thursday." We can hurt ourselves by "blackening" our reputation or be hurt by others by being "blacklisted," "blackballed," or "blackmailed" (Willams, 1965). When the Chicago White Sox deliberately lost the 1919 World Series as part of a betting scheme, they became known as the Chicago Black Sox, and to this day this "dark" chapter in American sports history is known as the Black Sox Scandal. In a similar vein, Muhammed Ali has observed that we refer to white cake as "anger food cake" and dark cake as "devil's food cake." (Frank & Gilovich 2008[1988]: 82-83)
Inner Party members dress in black.

Furlow, F. Bryant 2008[1996]. The Smell of Love. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 86-93.

The French physician Paul Broca - noting that primates' social olfactory abilities are diminished compared to those of other mammals - asserted that monkeys, apes, and humans represent ascending steps from four-legged sniffling beasts to sight-oriented bipeds. (Furlow 2008[1996]: 87)
Naked apes.
Scent and Sentiment
Curiously, remembering a smell is usually difficult - yet when exposed to certain scents, many people may suddenly recall a distant childhood memory in emotionally rich detail. Some aromas even affect us physiologically. Laboratory researchers exploring human olfaction have found that:
  • A faint trace of lemon significantly increases people's perception of their own health.
  • Lavender incense contributes to a pleasant mood - but it lowers volunteers' mathematical abilities.
  • A whiff of lavender and eucalyptus increases people's respiratory rate and aletrtness.
  • The scent of phenethil alcohol (a constituent of rose oil) reduces blood pressure.
Such findings have led to the rapid development of an aromatherapy industry. Aromatherapist point to scientific findings that smell can dramatically affect our moods as evidence that therapy with aromatic oils can help buyers manage their emotional lives.
Mood is demonstrably affected by scent. But scientists have found that, despite some extravagant industry promises, the attraction value in perfumes resides strictly in their pleasantness, not their sexiness. So far, at least, store-bought scent is more decoration than mood manager or love potion. A subtle "look this way" nudge to the nose, inspiring a stranger's curiosity, or at most a smile, is all perfume advertisers can in good conscience claim for their products - not overwhelming and immediate infatuation. (Furlow 2008[1996]: 87)
Industry promises are almost always exaggerated, though.
What could be a source of what might be our very own pheromone?
Humans possess three major types of skin glands - sebaceous glands, eccrine (or sweat) glands, and apocrine glands. Sebaceous glands are most common on the face and forehead but occur around all of the body's openings, including eyelids, ears, nostrils, lips, and nipples. This placement is particularly handy, as the secretions of these glands kill potentially dangerous microorganisms. They alse contain fats that keep skin supple and waterproof - and, on the downside, cause acne. Little is known, however, about how sebaceous glands contribute to human body odor.
The sweat glands exude water and salt and are nonodorous in healthy people. That leaves the third potential source of a human pheromone - the apocrine gland. Apocrine glands hold special promise as the source of smells that might affect interpersonal interactions. They do not serve any temperature-managing functions in people, as they do in other animals. They occur in dense concentrations on hands, cheeks, scalp, breast areolas, and wherever we possess body hair - and are only functional after puberty, when we begin searching for mates.
Men's apocrine glands are larger than women's, and they secrete most actively during times of nervousness or excitement. Waiting colonies of bacteria turn apocrine secretions into the nexious fumes that keep deodorant makers in business. Hair provides surface area from which apocrine smells can diffuse - part of the reason why hairier men smell particularly pungent.
Most promising of all, apocrine glands exude odorous steroids known to affect sexual behavior in other mammals. Androsterone - a steroid related to the one that nearly doomed the hapless musk deer - is one such substance. Men secrete more androsterone than women do, and most men become unable to detect the stuff right around the time they start producing it themselves - at puberty. (Furlow 2008[1996]: 88-89)
The search for the human pheromone is futile.
The empirical proof of odor's effect on human sexual attraction came out of left field. Medical geneticists studying inheritance rules for the immune system, not smell physiologists, made a series of crucial discoveries that nobody believed were relevant to human mate preferences - at first.
A segment of our DNA called the major histocompatibility complex (MCH) codes for some disease-detecting structures, which function as the immune system's eyes. When a disease is recognized, the immune system's teeth - the killer T cells - are alerted, and they swarm the intruders, smothering them with destructive enzymes. MHC genes are "co-dominant." This means that if a lab mouse inherits a version of an MHC gene for resistance to Disease A from its mother and a version lending resistance to Disease B from its father, that mouse will be able to resist both diseases. Interestingly, when a female mouse is offered two suitors in mate choice trials, she inevitably chooses to mate with the one whose MHC genes least overlap with her own. (Furlow 2008[1996]: 90)
This is supposedly an aspect of the age-old biological war between humans and bacteria. It is supposedly also the case that after a woman is impregnated or starts taking birth control pills, her "histocompatibility" preferences invert.

Ekman, Paul and Wallace V. Friesen 2008[1972]. Hand Movements. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 105-108.

Whatever the genesis, the intent seems clear. Whether it's the outstretched hand or the palms pressed together, each signal suggests openness and a clear sign that the greeter is not carrying a weapon.
Some believe the hug or embrace originally had a similar purpose: the assurance that no weapons were hidden beneath the flowing robes worn from the time of the Egyptians through the Middle Ages. (Ekman & Friesen 2008[1972]: 110)
This must be where Pease got the idea that shaking hands comes from the tradition of checking for concealed weapons.

Grumet, Gerald W. 2008[1983]. Eye Contact: The Core of Interpersonal Relatedness. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 119-129.

In about 450 B.C. the Greek philosopher Empedocles explained vision as resulting from a stream of fiery corpuscles passing first from the eye to the object of vision and returning to the eye. Plato later wrote, "They set the face in front ... and constructed light-bearing eyes, and caused pure fire to flow through the eyes" (Siegel, 1970, p. 24). Such ancient theories reflect the sense of power ascribed to sight that bedeviled scientific thought until the 17th century, when Kepler correctly proposed that they eye was an optical instrument able to form an image on its own retina. Vision had always carried with it a sense of graphic truth and authenticity, placing it in a position of prominenc among the senses. Soltis (1966) notes, "One of our firmest ordinary beliefs is that whatever object we take to be visually perceived by us do exist" (p. 111). Gibson (1960) adds, "Visual perceiving often enough does not feel like knowing; instead it feels like an immediately acquaintance or a direct contact" (p. 220). Freese (1977) points out that if discrepant sensory information is received, the influence of sight is likely to predominate: "Visual perception is capable of overriding all other information should any of it conflict with the visual sense" (p. 72). (Grumet 2008[1983]: 119-120)
This sense of graphic truth and authenticity could also be the reason why people reportedly trust nonverbal communication more than verbal communication. The phrase itself is neat.
Eye contact is usually a first step in interpersonal engagement, beginning a train of action that develops and defines the relationship between the gazer and gazed upon. As Garrison and Arensberg (1976) note, "On eye contact, predator and prey, or rival and rival, or lover and loved, are alerted, tensed for what may come next, and a move follows: predator or rival to the attack, lover to tactile approach..." (p. 292). (Grumet 2008[1983]: 121)
Eye contact precedes greetings in the phatic sequence (utterance → speech → communion). Physical proximity (which enables eye contact in the first place) in turn precedes eye contact.
It should be noted that there is a difference between "looking" and "staring." The former is dynamically tied to the subject's behavior and is influenced by it, whereas the latter is not responsive to the other person's behavior and persists regardless of it. The fear engendered by a stare was well depicted in a study by Ellsworth and coworkers (1972), who had an experimenter on a motorbike stare at motorists stopped for a red light at an intersection. Not surprisingly, these motorists' departure from the intersection was significantly more rapid when the light changed, paralleling the flight behavior of animals. The authors note that "gazing at a person's face is an exceedingly salient stimulus with interpersonal implications which cannot be ignored" (p. 311). This phenomenon was well demonstrated in the World Chess Championship between Viktor Korchnoi and Anatoly Karpov in 1978. The Russian entourage supporting Karpov included Vladimir Zukhar, a parapsychologist and hypnotist: "His only job seemed to be to sit up front and stare at Korchnoi with his bulging, scary eyes. By the third game, Korchnoi was convinced he was being hypnotized. ... At game 7, Korchnoi, a nervous wreck by that time - and with Karpov way ahead in the match - started to yell, saying he would descent from the stage and poke Zukhar in the nose. Zukhar was moved to a seventh-row seat." (Schonberg, 1981, p. 37). (Grumet 2008[1983]: 122)
Lack of nonverbal ethics. I was once stared intensely by a group of students in the library. I assumed it was a group of psychology students working on exactly this topic. It made me uncomfortable, but without looking their way I could proceed working.
Direct eye contact between strangers may, on occasion, be described as "love at first sight," which is implied in the lyrics of "Some Enchanted Evening" by Oscar Hammerstein II:
Some enchanted evening, you may see a stranger;
You may see a stranger across a crowded room;
And somehow you know, you know even then,
That somewhere you'll see her again and again.
The song suggests that a single glance at an unfamiliar person can produce an enormous emotional impact. While a one-way glance signifies one person's interest in another, a mutual glance signifies the inception of a relationship or what has been variously called "shared interocular intimacy" (Tomkins, p. 157), "participation in a wordless exchange" (Exline, 1963, p. 3), or "consciousness of consciousness" (Sartre, 1953, p. 363). (Grumet 2008[1983]: 123)
Or in Bateson's terms, mutual awareness and perception.
Willingness to Relate: A person's decision to look back into the eyes of someone who is already looking at him is one of the principal signals by which one denotes a willingness to begin an encounter, for ocular engagement reflects human engagement. Mutual gaze or "catching someone's eye" indicates the entrance into a relationship and may be consciously manipulated toward this end. Common examples are efforts to establish ocural contact with a waiter in a restaurant or to avoid establishing eye contact with a beggar on the street. (Grumet 2008[1983]: 125-126)
Definitely the stuff of phatics.

Kraut, Robert E. and Robert E. Johnston 2008[1979]. Social and Emotional Messages of Smiling. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 139-143.

Many nonhuman primates have a submissive facial display, called a grimace, a grin, or a silent bared-teeth face. The display resembles the human smile, and in all species in which it occurs, it seems to have the function of deflecting hostile behavior of more dominant animals (Hooff, 1962). Hooff hypothesized that the human smile is evolutionarily related to the chimpanzee's bared-teeth displays and serves the same functions of deflecting hostility and maintaining friendly contact. On the other hand, according to Hooff, laughter evolved independently and is related to the primate "play face."
If human smiling does serve a friendliness function, one would expect smiling to occur most in face-to-face interaction, especially where friendly intent is problematic or where social bonds are being established or renewed. The smiler's motivation may be genuine friendliness or an intent to establish friendly relations. Researchers in this ethological tradition have not been concerned with the emotions or feelings experienced by those doing the smiling. (Kraut & Johnston 2008[1979]: 140)
Smiling in this sense is also related to phatics, although neither Malinowski's or Jakobson's varieties, but rather something like "nonverbal phatics".
Results: The observations revealed that bowlers smiled often when they were socially engaged and looking at or talking to others. In contrast, bowlers smiled less after scoring a spare or strike. Similarly, bowlers rarely smiled while facing the pins or when bowling alone. However, they smiled frequently when facing their friends. Overall, bowlers appeared "happier" about their bowling success when their friends were present as compared to when they were alone. At the hockey game, fans smiled both when they were socially involved with others and after events favorable to their team occurred. Finally, pedestrians were much more likely to smile when talking to others than when alone. Pedestrians walking in pleasant weather were only slightly more likely to smile than those walking in unpleasant weather. Taken together, these suggest that smiling is much more motivated by social interaction and the desire to appear friendly than by internal feelings of happiness. (Kraut & Johnston 2008[1979]: 141)
E.g. smiling is more phatic (has a "social function") rather than emotive.

Farinelli, Lisa 2008. The Sounds of Seduction and Affection. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 160-168.

According to Givens, the seducer sees someone that he or she finds attractive, then works to grab the attention of the attractive person, and finally works to alleviate uncertainty between him- or herself and the target of the seduction. (Farinelli 2008: 161)
Appeal (conative function), and an information-theoretical approach (uncertainty, entropy).
So, the male seducer wants to appear strong at first and then tender. But what do females try to convey? The answer may surprise you. According to flirtation researcher Monica Moore (1995), "girls just wanna have fun" (p. 319). Moore planted herself on a college campus in a singles bar, a library, a snack bar, and a meeting. As time passed, she watched the strategic moves of women to grab male attention. What did she find? Women had fun! They laughed, usually tossing their heads back first. Sometimes they giggled, using a toned-down laugh. And sometimes they put their mouths by people's ears and whispered, a move intended to make the opposite sex's resistance weaken. But it isn't just college women who seem to know the secret to having fun when flirting: adolescent girl do, too. Moore (1995) observed adolescent girs in mixed sex settings and found that they, too, laughed, giggled, and whispered in their courtship behavior. Males might laugh, but when conveying interest in the opposite sex, usually tilting their heads or leaning forward (Grammer, 1990). (Farinelli 2008: 163-164)
So women tend to convey youthfulness (adelescent-ness?) when they flirt?
The communication of affection is a vital aspect of life, with people who give and receive affection reporting more mental and physical health (Floyd, 2006; Morman & Floyd, 1998). Floyd and Voloudakis (1999) defined affectionate communication as "the direct or indirect expression of affectionate feelings for the other" (pp. 342-434). As noted by Floyd and Ray (2003), although affection is certainly important in later stages of relationships, it can also play a significant role during the first encounters between two people because of "its ability to contribute to relational development" (p. 56). (Farinelli 2008: 164)
Affection and phatics? At this point it would appear than anything to do with human relations in terms of communication can be jotted down as phatics.

Jaworski, Adam 2008[1993]. The Power of Silence in Communication. In: Guerrero, Laura K. and Michael L. Hecht (eds.), The Nonverbal Communication Reader: Classic and Contemporary Readings. Third Edition. Long Grove: Waveland Press, 175-181.

Positive and Negative Values of Silence
When silence is recognized as a possible means of communication, it is typically considered to be able to express a variety of meanings and to perform a range of functions. A number of researchers have pointed out these properties of silence and have indicated that, on a number of planes, silence has two values: positive and negative. For example, Jensen (1973) discusses five functions of silence and assigns a positive and a negative value to each of them. The functions he proposes are as follows:
  • A linkage function: Silence may bond two (or more) people or it may separate them.
  • An affective function: Silence may heal (over time) or wound.
  • A revelation function: Silence may make something known to a person (self-exploration) or it may hide information from others.
  • A judgmental function: Silence may signal assent and favor or it may signal dissent and disfavor.
  • An activation function: Silence may signal deep thoughtfulness (work) or it may signal mental inactivity.
Tannen (1985) discusses the "positive and negative valuation of silence" in regard to a number of communicative and social processes. Following Allen (1978), Tannen (1985) says "that silence serves two functions in the literature she [Allen] surveyed, one negative - a failure of language - and one positive - a chance for personal exploration" (p. 94). Furthermore, Tannen lists different types of situations in which silence may function in such an ambivalent manner: either as an expression of good or bad rapport and either as comfortable or clumsy communication. (Jaworski 2008[1993]: 179-180)
Here thi "linkage function" is phatic. Could the other four be compared to Jakobson's?
A similar ambivalence of silence is observed in the cultural communicative uses of silence in Japanese (Lebra, 1987). The value of silence in Japan derives from the conceptualization of the self as split into two parts: the inner and the outward. The inner is associated with truthfulness and is located symbolically in the heart and belly. The outward is associated with the face, mouth, and spoken words and with deception, disguise, falsity, and so on, whereas silence expresses inner truth. Reticent individuals are trusted as honest, sincere, and straightforward. Thus silence is an active state, while speech is an excuse for delaying activity. (Jaworski 2008[1993]: 180)
This is opposed to what we can read from Malinowski: "to a natural man, another man's silence is not a reassuring factor, but, on the contrary, something alarming and dangerous" (Malinowski 1946[1923]: 314).

DNF. I quit halfway through because this book is excruciatingly boring.

Exchange and Power in Social Life

Blau, Peter M. 1964. Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York; London; Sydney: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Radical political opposition, for example, crannot be explained without taking into account the expressive significance it has for supporters, and failure to do so is a sorious shortcoming of formalistically rational models of politics. Such political opposition that express the resentment of the oppressed can, however, be derived from a conception of exchange without resort to the assumption that the push of irrational impulses or psychopathic personality traits of drive individuals to become radicals. Similarly, in intimate relations of intrinsic significance, individuals often do favors for one another not in the expectation of receiving explicit repayments but to express their commitment to the interpersonal relation and sustain it bp encouraging an increasing commitment on the part of the other. There is still an element of exchange in doing favors to strengthen another's commitment that one desires, though only in the broadest sense of the term. (Blau 1964: 6)
"Intrinsically significant" relations sound neatly technical.
Opposition to existing powers in conceived in chapter nine as grounded in the unfair treatment experienced by an oppressed collectivity with extensive social communication among themselves and in their desire to retaliate for the injustice and exploitation they have suffered. Radical opposition to an oppressive ruling group could not arise were it not for the expressive significance this manifestation of their collective vengeance has for the exploited, because a ruling group has the power to make opposition to it disadvantageous, which would preclude opposition were subjects to engage in it only on strictly rational grounds. Oppression and deprivation often produce a social surplus, since they tend to make some men willing to sacrifice material welfare for the sake of opposition ideals and hence free human energies to join in opposition to the oppressors. A dilemma a radical opposition partiy is likely to face is that widening the appeal of its ideology requires compromises that may well weaken the commitment of its most devoted supporters. (Blau 1964: 9-10)
Yup, there are many disadvantages to being in radical opposition to oppression. That is to say that it is difficult to go against the grain or to swim upstream.
When the consciousness of individuals, instead of remaining isolated, becomes grouped and combined, something in the world has been altered. (Emile Durkheim, Suicide)
True, but this contention is also driven to the extreme in cases when grouping and combination of individuals is brought on by an instruction or command. E.g. all the unproductive group exercises a student is forced to join.
Physical pleasures that can be experienced in solitude pale in significance bp comparison. Enjoyable as a good dinner is, it is the social occasion that gives it its luster. Indeed, there is something pathetic about a person who derives his major gratification from food or drink as such, since it reveals either excessive need or excessive greed; the pauper illustrates the former, the glutton, the latter. To be sure, there are profound solitary enjoyments - reading a good book, creating a piece of art, producing a scholarly mork. Yet these, too, derive much of their significance from being later communicated to and shared with others. The lack of such anticipation makes the solitary activity again somewhat pathetic: the recluse who has nobody to talk to about what he reads; the artist or scholar whose works are completely ignored, not only by his contemporaries but also by posterity. (Blau 1964: 14-15)
I think there is intrinsic worth in schoralship as well: the thirst for knowledge, for example. Also, the internet and academic blogging make the matter of "communicating and sharing with others" a murky affair.
The social approval of those whose opinions we value is of great significance to us, but its significance depends on its being genuine. We cannot force others to give us their approval, regardless of how much power we have over them, because coercing them to express their admiration or praise would make these expressions worthless. "Action can be coerced, but a coerced show of feeling is only a show." (Blau 1964: 17)
Quite important sentiment.
Collective disapproval of power engenders opposition. People who share the experience of being exploited by the unfair demands of those in position of power, and by the insufficient rewards they receive for their contributions, are likely to communicate their feelings of anger, frustration, and aggression to each other. There tends to arise a wish to retaliate by striking down the existing powers. (Blau 1964: 23)
Today this is a bit different. Not only are these feelings communicated to each other, but to the whole human population via social media. And then it happens that the whole world wishes to strike down the oppressors. E.g. the recent case of peaceful demonstrations in Turkey against building a mall in place of the last existing park in central Istanbul. The injustice is readily recognizable to everyone and this arises collective empathy. Surely there have always been "dissident letters" and manifests by scholars etc. but these travelled by snail mail while the new age brings live video feed across the glove in an instant.
Institutionalization refers to the emergence of social mechanisms through which social values and norms, organizing principles, and knowledge and skills are transmitted from generation to generation. A society's institutions constitute the social matrix in which individuals grow up and are socialized, with the result that some aspects of institutions are reflected in their own personalities, and others appear to them as the inevitable external conditions of human existence. Traditional institutions stabilize social life but also introduce rigidities that make adjustment to changing conditions difficult. Opposition movements may arise to promote such adjustment, yet these movements themselves tend to become institutionalized and rigid in the course of time, creating needs for fresh oppositions. (Blau 1964: 25)
In the first instance similar to Hall's claim that bureaucracies tend to grow out of proportion and forget their original aim. In the second instance similar to Matthiesen's claim that "the system" has a way of neutralizing opposition (e.g. Rahvakogu).
Social reactions to the exercise of power reflect once more the principle of reciprocity and imbalance, although in a new form. Power over others makes it impossible to direct and organize their activities. Sufficient resources to command power over large numbers enable a person or group to establish a large organization. The members recruited to the organization receive benefits, such as financial remuneration, in exchange for complying with the directives of superiors and making various contributions to the organization. The leadership exercises power within the organization, nad it derives powel from the organization for use in relation with other organizations or groups. The clearest illustration of this double power of organizational leadership is the army commander's power over his own soldiers and ,through the force of their arms, over the enemy. Another example is the power business management exercises over its own employees and, through the strength of the concern, in themarket. The greater the external power of an organization, the greater are its chances of accumulating resources that put rewards at the disposal of the leadership for possible distribbution among its members. (Blau 1964: 29)
The power structure of organization, based on exchange relations.
If the demands of the men who exercise power are experienced by those subject to it as exploitative and oppressive, and particularly if these subordinates have been unsuccessful in obtaining redress for their grievances, their frustrations tend to promote disapproval of existing powers and antagonism torward them. As the oppressed communicate their anger and aggression to each other, provided there are opportunities for doing so, their mutual support and approval socially justify and reinforce the negative orientation toward the oppressors, and their collective hostility may inspire them to organize an opposition. The exploitative use of coercive power that arouses active opposition is more prevalent in the relations between organizations and groups than within organizations. Two reasons for this are that the advantages of legitimating approval restrain organizational superiors and that the effectiveness of legitimate authority, once established, obviates the need for coercive measures. But the exploitative use of power also occurs within organizations, as unions organize in opposition to exploitative employers show. A negative imbalance for the subjects of power stimulates opposition. The opposition negatively reciprocates, or retaliates, for excessive demands in an attempt to even the score, but it simultaneously creates conflict, disequilibrium, and imbalance in the social structure. (Blau 1964: 30)
The need for disengagement or distance from oppressive organizations.
To make a good impression, a person must infer which of his qualities would do so in a given group and adapt his conduct accordingly. Self-conscious concern with impressing others, however, can easily become self-defeating. If an individual is too self-conscious, his awkwardness will leave a poor impression, and if others suspect his of deliberately putting up a front, he also will have made an unfavorable impression. Creating a good first impression is a subtle form of bragging, but its success depends on its being so natural that it does not appear to be bragging at all. (Blau 1964: 39)
This stance is invaluable for an analysis of self-presentations.
Men are anxious to receive social approval for their decisions and actions, for their opinions and suggestions. The approving agreement of others helps to confirm their judgments, to justify their conduct, and to validate their beliefs. Factual decisions, which are either true or false in terms of an outside criterion, often engenders doubts and anxieties regarding their correctness, which are dispelled if associates whose judgment is respected concur in the decision. The values of men that govern their opinions and behavior cannot be considered true or false on the basis of any objective criterion, but this makes it even more important to receive the confirming approval of others. For it is the stamp of approval social agreement bestows on our values that validates them. Social consensus defines beliefs as right or wrong. Although it is possible for men to maintain convictions in the face of contrary public opinion, it is most difficult to do so; and the more at odds a man's beliefs are with prevailing values, the more important it is for him to receive some social support to sustain them. (Blau 1964: 62)
Orthodoxy is easier.
Superior status, whether it rests on the respect of a person commands or on his official position of power, makes his approval important for others. The high value of his approval permits him to use it sparingly despite group pressures for greater leniency, although there are, of course, individual differences in the tendency to yield to these pressures. The individual who neither occupies a superior official position nor is highly respected is under constraints to use his less valuable approbation more freely. His approval is not in great demand, particularly not by those whose competence enables them to receive praise from more respected persons. Hence, for his approval to have any impact at all, he must be willing to furnish it for decisions of only mediocre quality. (Blau 1964: 64)
If you're an average bloke, concern yourself with matters of average importance.
An individual's endeavors to gain social acceptance in a group are furthered most by the approval of highly respected group members, since their approving opinions of him influence the opinions of others and thus have a multiplier effect. Highly respected persons, however, tend to reserve their approval for outstanding qualifications and not to express it for mere conformity. To win their approbation, consequently, an individual must show that he has some superior abilities. The fact that even social acceptance is experienced by making an outstanding impression on others reinforce the tendency of new group members to demonstrate their impressive qualities, although acceptance as a peer does not require outstanding abilities and can be won, if more slowly, by establishing common links with other members, expressing opinions they share, and conforming to the prevailing norms among them. (Blau 1964: 67)
I'd rather aquire superior abilities than settle for the acceptance of peers.
Expressions of intrinsic attraction to an individual, just as expressions of approval of him, are expected to be spontateous reactions to his qualities; they lose their significance for him if it becomes apparent that they are calculated to have a certain effect on him, though it be only to give him pleasure. A man who seeks affection by internalized normative standards of judgment, and intrinsic attraction, by an internal emotional reaction. The stimulation of either is condemned. Approval of an individual's specific qualities that becomes diffuse approval of his composite qualities as a person is the source of intrinsic attraction to him. (Blau 1964: 69)
This reminds me of difference between a compliment and a praise: a compliment is calculated praise while geniune praise is spontaneous.
Finally, the gratification a woman experiences as the result of being loved by a man are greatly enhanced if she loves him too, and this may unconsciously incline her to return his love. The love of a man animates a woman and makes her a more fascinating and attractive person. Going out with a man who is in love with her enhances her self-image as a captivating woman and thus probably offects her behavior to make her actually more charming and appealing. For a man's loving admiration to have pronounced effects on her self-image and conduct, however, his estimation of her must be of great significance for her. A woman's love for a man who loves her, therefore, helps to make her a more charming and self-confident person, because it magnifies, as it were, the mirror that reflects and partly shapes her personality as a lover. Although a woman cannot will herself to love a man who loves her, the advantages she gains from reciprocating his love may unconsciously motivate her to do so. (Blau 1964: 83)
I'm actually getting tired of this. It sounds like "an economist's theory of social behaviour," which it indeed in a way is.
There are, then, numerous parallels between expressions of affection in love relations and expressions of approval in social associations generally. There are also some contrasts, however. The main source of the difference is that the condition in a collective structure largely govern the significance of social approval while the conditions established by a pair of lovers themselves primarily govern the significance of their affection for one another, although pair relations modify the significance of approval and the broader social situation affects the significance of affection, too. The baseline of prestige that makes others appreciate an individual's approval and the baseline of attraction that makes others appreciate an individual's affection rest on different foundations, since prestige is typically more firmly rooted in the social structure than is attraction. (Blau 1964: 86-87)
I can't follow the thought any more, but I keep typing these notes in case that I some day may.
Mauss and other anthropologists have called attention tot he significance and prevalence of the exchange of gifts andd services in simpler societies. "In theory such gifts are voluntary but in fact they are given and repaid under obligation. ... Further, what they exchange is not exclusively foods and wealth, real and personal property, and things of economic value. They exchange rather courtesies, entertainments, ritual, military assistance, women, children, dances, and feasts; and fairs in which the market is but one element and the circulation of wealth but one part of a wide and enduring contact." (Blau 1964: 89)
That is, there are other aspects to social exchange than economic considerations.
"'Power' (Macht) is the probability that one actor within a social relationship will be in a position to carry out his own will despite resistance," according to Weber. Tawney's definition similarly centers on imposing one's will on others, except that he explicitly directs attention to the asymmetry of power relations: "Power may be defined as the capacity of an individual, or group of individuals, to modify the condduct of other individuals or groups in the manner which he desires, and to prevent his own conduct being modified in the manner in which he does not." (Blau 1964: 115)
Another definition of power to be thrown into the pool of so many others.
Talcott Parsons makes a parallel distinction between coercive power that rests on deterrence through negative sanctions and inducements in exchange transactions that rest on positive sanctions; "On the Concept of Influence," Public Opinion Quarterly, 27 (1963), 43-45, and "On the Concept of Political Power," Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 107 (1963), 238-239. (Blau 1964: 116; footnote 5)
Som references.
Superior coercive power makes people relatively independent of others inasmuch as power includes the ability to prevent others from interfering with one's conduct. (Blau 1964: 120)
Autonomy as a tenet of power.

Understanding communication theory (memo)

Cragan, John F. and Donald C. Shields 1998. Understanding communication theory: the communicative forces for human action. Boston, etc.: Allyn and Bacon.

1. Introduction to Communication Theory
2. Information Systems Theory (IST)
3. Rational Argumentation Theory (RAT)
4. Symbolic Convergence Theory (SCT)
5. Uncertainly Reduction Theory (URT)
6. Narrative Paradigm Theory (NPT)
7. Diffusion of Innovations Theory (DIT)
8. Interpersonal and Small Group Communication Context Theories
9. Public Speaking and Organizational Communication Context Theories
10. Mass and Intercultural Communication Context Theories
11. Communication Microtheories
12. Capstone
During the twentieth century, theorists began concluding that symbolic facts exist just like material and social facts. George Herbert Mead (1938) left us with the notion of communication as symbolic interaction. Flew (1985), by including the symbolic realm, extended Berger and Luckman's (1966) notion about the social construction of reality. Bormann abandoned the social construction of reality and introduced the notion of the symbolic construction of reality (1980, 1985b). These and other theorists contributed procedures to ascertain the presence of symbolic facts. Symbolic facts are language representations that provide interpretations of the way things are. They may or may not possess a referent in social or material reality. Today, symbolic facts include such entities as worldview, ideologies, myths, interpretive frames, ideographs, perspectives, speech codes, and rhetorical visions. (Cragan & Shields 1998: 322)
  • Berger, C. R., & Calabrese, R. J. 1975. Some explorations in initial interaction and beyond: Toward a developmental theory of interpersonal communication. Human Communication Research 1(2): 90-112.
    This paper provides a theoretical perspective for dealing with the initial entry stage of interpersonal interaction. The seven axioms and 21 theorems presented suggest a set of research priorities for studying the development of interpersonal relationships. The paper concludes with a discussion of some of the problems to be considered if the theory is to be extended beyond the initial stages of interaction.
  • Griffith, B. C. 1989. Understanding science: Studies of communication and information. Communication Research 16: 600-614.
    A diverse group of researchers and scholars has achieved a better understanding of social and cognitive processes, general throughout science. The key elements proved to be communication and information. Communication is the only general scientific behavior; other behaviors are mostly specific and technical. Information and its representations are its principal and general artifacts. This article explores the development of theory and the discovery of some strong empirical relationships among measured communication and information that, in turn, capture important features of social process and cognitive change in science.
  • Flew, Anthony 1985. Thinking about social thinking: The philosophy of the social sciences. New York: Basil Blackwell.
    Rationalizing human behavior is our most compelling pastime. We are all disposed to offer and accept insufficient evidence and invalid arguments when these seem to support conclusions that we merely wish were true. We need to know how clearly about our social thinking and how to resist the allure of self-deception, everyone skeptical about or confused by the findings of the social sciences will appreciate Antony Flew's crisp analysis of the methodological flaws and systematic misunderstandings corrupting their content and application. Thinking About Social Thinking seeks to establish what can and cannot be learned from such studies, indicating where good work has been ignored, or much-needed work has yet to be done. Flew's clear and incisive arguments are illustrated with abundant examples and references -- many entertaining, others surprising. Flew issues a refreshing, impassioned warning against the perils of complacent, muddled thinking and false but comfortable conclusions.

Kehakeele survey

Olen hakanud tundma, et nii intensiivselt võõrkeeles lugedes-kirjutades läheb emakeel justkui kaduma. Mul ei ole aega ega tahtmist, et pöörduda tagasi eestikeelse kirjanduse ja kommenteerimise juurde, aga argivajaduste rahuldamiseks on võibolla kasulik teha uuring/vaatlus/mõõdistus (survey) sellest mida võib leida kui googeldada sõna "kehakeel". See võib olla ka ajalooliselt huvitav ülevaade, sest päringutulemused kahtlemata muutuvad ajas ja siis saab hiljem järele vaadata millist informatsiooni varem saadaval oli. Hea oleks kui see oleks korduv ülesanne, ehk teeksin aeg-ajalt uuesti sellise survey ja vaatan mis on lisandunud. On ka väga tõenäoline, et kui ma märksõnu "kehakeel" ja "mitteverbaalne suhtlemine" siin tihedasti kasutan, siis jõuab ka see postitus aktuaalsete päringute hulka ja kehakeelest huvi tundvad inimesed leiavad üles kogu selle kirjanduse mida see blogi kehakeele kohta sisaldab.

Hoiatan ette ära, et selline uuring pole mitte mingis mõttes objektiivne. Kommentaarid ja arvamused on subjektiivsed - minule ainuomased - ja neid ei tasuks võtta liiga tõsiselt. Teen seda esmatähtsalt enda jaoks.

Neile, kes sattusid siia selle tõttu, et otsivad kehakeelt käsitlevat kirjandust, siis siia nupule vajutades leiate nimekirja sellest mis on Eestis või Internetis saadaval:



PealkiriKehakeel | Facebook
Linkhttps://www.facebook.com/pages/Kehakeel/156239954415747
LühiväljavõteKehakeel. 189 likes · 5 talking about this. ... December · November · October. Kehakeel is on Facebook. To connect with Kehakeel, sign up for Facebook today.

"Kehakeel" on siin metafoorilises kasutuses. Tegu on joogaharrastajatest taimetoitlaste arusaamaga, et keha... kõneleb? Kirjeldus kõlab: "Keha on hinge kodu, koosnedes sõna otsese mõttes sellest, mida sa sööd! Et oma keha eest paremini hoolitseda ning olla tasakaalus oma keha hinge ja meelega." Samad tegelased on ära registreerinud domeeni www.kehakeel.com - alateemad selles blogis on Kehakeelest, Toitumisest, Taimetoitlusest, Toitumisnõustamine, Joogast, Sündmused, Endast ja Kokkamine. Viimane sissekanne on teemal "Kõhnade inimeste diskrimineerimine". Klikkides alateemale "Kehakeelest", avanab Aadama ja Eeva pildiga tekst mis algab nii: "Univesum on tekkinud miljardeid aastaid tagasi ning meie maa, inimesed, loomad, linnud, puud ja putukad on üks osa sellest. Meie keha koosneb samadest elementidest nagu tähed taevas-kaltsium, magneesium jne. Iga süsteem, millele me igapäevaselt tähelepanu ei pööra nagu uue elu loomine, sündimine, söömine, seedimine, suremine on osake keerulisest mehanismist..." Kehakeele kui mitteverbaalse suhtlemisega pole siin mingit pistmist. Egle Koppel, selle värgi eestvedaja, võibolla arvas, et "kehakeel" on selline tühja tähistaja moodi sõna mida võib kasutada nagu Humpty Dumpty. Ma ei saa seda talle pahaks panna. Kahju vaid sellest, et taoline käitumine veel enam süvendam argiteadmuslikku eelarvamust, et "kehakeel" on midagi müstilist, spirituaalset, või "midagi millega eided tegelevad" (if you excuse my french). Joogat annab küll mitteverbaalse suhtlemisega siduda, läbi selle, et kindlasti on harjutusi mis parandavad kehalist väljendusvõimekust... Aga muu poolest on ettevõtmine minu silmis mööda pannud. Ma eeldan, et selliseid me-ei-tea-mis-kehakeel-on-aga-kasutame-seda-sõna-ikkagi ettevõtmisi on veel.


PealkiriKehakeel - Vikipeedia, vaba entsüklopeedia
Linkhttp://et.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kehakeel
LühiväljavõteMitteverbaalne kommunikatsioon ehk kehakeel hõlmab nii inimese liikumist (hoiak, žestid, naeratus, silmakontakt ja füüsikalise ruumi kasutamine) kui ka ...

Selle lehekülje kohta on juba midagi asjalikku öelda. Artikli alguses on suur hoiatusmärk: "Võimalik autoriõiguste rikkumine!" See on põhjustatud tõsiasjast, et tegu on Saaremaa Ühisgümnaasiumi lõpetaja uurimistööga Kehakeelest. Selle uurimustöö kasutatud kirjanduse hulgas on Tuurannu kriminoloogiline juhend, kellegi D. Glošin'i 2008. aasta uurimustöö (dunno), Kevin Hogani "The Secrets of Body Language" (rämps), kellegi J. Nowakowsky artikkel "Constructivist Model for Learning" (pole töös sees vist isegi kasutatud), eestikeelne Nierenberg (1997), eestikeelne Pease (1994), kellegi L. Plonka 2007. Keha Kõneleb, kellegi C. Topf 1998. Kehakeel ja edukas karjäär, ja paar internetilehekülge. Lühidalt, materjal mida on võimalik leida kohalikust raamatukogust või internetist. Mingil hetkel tuleks mul endal ka need allikad üle lugeda, aga see oleks ikka väga kriitline ettevõtmine niiet pean ennast veel koguma. Samas, loogiline järjestus olekski eestikeelsete raamatute lugemine enne kui eestikeelset veebi analüüsin, sest esimene paratamatult mõjutab teist. Esialgu proovin ilma, ehk on põnevam kui kohe autoreid ära ei taba.
Artiklit/uurimustööd ennast väga kommenteerida ei taha, sest see on sisuliselt refereering ja midagi uut see ei ütle. Pigem karjub see wiki-lehekülg hädasti toimetamise järele. Ilmselt mina ise olen kõige asisem inimene seda toimetama, aga see jällegi eeldab, et ma oskaksin eesti keelt piisavalt, et enne ingliskeelne eestikeelseks tõlkida ja siis oma teadmised-parandused sellele lisada. Tülikas juba suuruste tõttu: praegune uurimustöö on (wiki PDF-ina) 15 lehekülge; ingliskeelne artikkel Body Language on kõigest 5 lehekülge, aga Nonverbal Communication on 13 lehekülge ja täis väga asist teksti mida on raske toimetada. Kunagi peaksin paratamatult selle töö ära tegema, aga selle poole tuleb ehitada. Praegu alustan sellest, et uurin oma Survey-ga välja mida eestlased üldse kehakeelest teavad või teada tahavad.
See uurimustöö võib isegi olla väga sümptomaatiline selle suhtes mida peaks korralik wikiartikkel käsitlema. Mul on nende aspektide kohta siin blogis rohkemal või vähemal määral igaühe kohta informatsiooni mis tuleks vaid läbi töödata ja eesti keeles õigesti esitada. Need alapealkirjad uurimustööst võivad seega isegi kasulikuks osutuda:
Kommunikatsioonisüsteemid; Kehakeele liigitamine; Põhilised suhtlemisžestid ja nende päritolu; Kehakeel; Žestide tähtsus; Ühiskondlik seisund ja žestide rohkus; Kehakeele võltsimine; Näoilme; Pilkkontakt; Signaalid silmadega; Naeratus; Kurameerimisliigutused ja signaalid; Kõnnak ja kehahoid; Peahoiak; Käesurumine; Avatud peopesad; Näo puudutamine; Kuulamine; Käed kui tõkked; Jalgadest kaitsetõke; Vastuvõtlikkus, intuitsioon kehakeele lugemisel; Avatus, kaitseseisund, hindamine, kahtlustamine; Avatus; Kaitseseisund; Kahtlustamine ja salatsemine; Hindamine; Ruumivöönd; Ruumivööndid; Peegelpilt. Alateadlik kopeerimine; Enesekindlus, ärevus, kontroll; Ärevus; Allasurutud emotsioonid; Leke; Laps ja täiskasvanu.


PealkiriKehakeel
Linkhttp://www.kehakeel.ee/
Lühiväljavõte10 okt. 2012 – Inimese kaalust ehk sellest kui palju keegi on juurde või alla võtnud räägitakse pea iga päev. Ülekaalulisus on saanud epideemiaks terves ...

Jälle see, Jeebus. Ühest käest tahaks pahandada, et kehakeelel (nagu mina seda mõistan) ei ole mingit pistmist nende tegelaste Kehakeelega. Teisest käest on ka www.bodylanguage.com vaba (osta domeen), www.bodylanguage.net on "The UK & International Journal of Medical Aesthetics and Anti-Ageing" koduleht ja www.bodylanguage.org ütleb "Body Language ® is a medically-based program featuring women’s and children’s health and wellness issues". Võibolla hoopis mina eksin? Näib, et kehakeel ongi mitte ainult nende üksikute eestlaste vaid ka ülejäänud maailma silmis midagi mis on seotud tervise ja iluga. Või kas lugu võib olla selline, et teaduslikult kõlav nonverbal communication on meeste mängumaa ja lihtsameelne body language on siis see millega naised tegelevad? A la üks käsitleb kehalist suhtlemist, teine keha kui ilueset? Eks järgmiste lehekülgedega paljastub rohkem, sest juba ette näen, et paljud on saitidelt naistekas.delfi.ee ja naine24.ee - Oh lawd what have I gotten myself into.

[sardooniline märkus: nende ettevõtmine peaks olema pigem Kehakaal, amirite?]


PealkiriKehakeel - Miksike
Linkhttp://www.miksike.ee/docs/referaadid2006/kehakeel_kullikorol.htm
LühiväljavõteKehakeel. Sissejuhatus. Sõnade abil anname edasi vaid 7% teabest, hääle abil 38 %, mittesõnaliste vahendite kaudu 55%. Sõnade abil väljendame teavet, ...

Kui ma väike olin siis näis Miksike olevat väga tõsiseltvõetav allikas internetis. Seepärast kavatsen seda lehekülge tegelikult ka lugeda.
Referaat on koostatud http://www.cs.ut.ee/~karinr/KEHAK.html põhjal.
Link enam ei tööta. Vb isegi hea, sest see tekst alustab Mehrabiani müüdi kordamisest.
Sõnade abil väljendame teavet, keha abil aga isikutevahelisi suhteid.
See pole niivõrd müüt kuiet lihtsalt vale. Verbaalse suhtlemise kaudu väljendame ka teavet inimestevaheliste suhete kohta. Seesamune Mehrabian uuris ka lähedust (immediacy) keeles. Rääkimata sellest, et keha abil saab igasugust teavet - vb isegi kõige tähtsamat teavet oma isikute kohta - väljendada.
Väljend “kuues meel” tuleneb sellest, et me tunnetame eelaimust vestluskaaslase valelikkuse suhtes, kuna me märkasime vastuolu kaaslase sõnade ja kehakeele vahel. Tavaliselt on naised selliste juhtude puhul tundlikumad, sellest ka “naiselik vaist”.
Ei, ma olen päris kindel, et kuues meel ei pärine mitteverbaalse suhtlemise diskursusest vaid, et sellel on midagi pistmist spirituaalsusega. Kuues meel on extrasensory, meeleväline; mitteverbaalne suhtlemine on seotud meeltega. Ja naised ei ole tavaliselt tundlikumad ja "naiselik vaist" ei ole sellega nii lihtsalt seotud. Juba 70ndatel tehti kindlaks, et meeste ja naiste võimed emotsiooniväljenduste tõlgendamisel on enam-vähem samavõrd pädevad.
Nagu iga keel, nii koosneb ka kehakeel lausetest ja kirjavahemärkidest.
Kineesika - lingvistika analoog on siin läinud nässu: kehakeele vaatlemine keelena on metodoloogiline vahend, mitte ontoloogiline tõde (see on viis kuidas sellest mõelda, mitte nii nagu asjad on).
Igal inimesel on oma keha ümbritsev õhuruum, mille suurus erineb meie elukohast ning sealsest inimeste arvust.
Ma pole kunagi täheldanud, et personal space oleks kuidagi seotud õhuga. "Õhuruum" kõlab nagu inimesed on lennukid. Aga õhk on tõepoolest see milles me elame.
Avameelne inimene sirutab teiega vesteldes oma käed ettepoole ning jätab peopesad avatuks. Inimene, kelle peopesad on avatud, valetab vähem. Samuti saame sel kombel teisi inimesi mõjutada vähem valetama, kuna meie avatud peopesad innustavad partnerit meisse siiralt suhtuma.
Tegelikult on asi pisut teistmoodi (vastupidi): kui inimene valetab siis näitab ta avatud peopesasid vähem. Kui ma ei eksi siis pärineb see tähelepanek Ekmani ja Frieseni artiklist "Hand Movements" ajakirjast Journal of Communication (Vol. 22(4), December 1972). Seda aga, et teistele avatud peopesade näitamine mõjutab teisi vähem valetama, selle suhtes pole ma üldse kindel.
Pettusest märkuandvate žestide äratundmine aitab meil aimata, et inimene valetab. Valetaja puudutab tihtipeale kätega nägu, püüdes katta suud, silmi või kõrvu. Samuti võivad need liigutused tähendada kahtlust, ebakindlust või liialdamist
See oli Allan Pease'i tõlgendus, et automanipulaatorite funktsioon on "katta" ehk sulgeda kanal - nt "katan silmad, ei taha näha". Tegelikkuses on sel rohkem pistmist tundlike nahakudedega mis hakkavad sügelema ebamugavustunde puhul. See on endokrinoloogia valdkond kus metafooridega saab vähe teha.
Suu juurde pannakse käsi seetõttu, kuna aju annab alateadvuses märku keelele tulevaid luiskesõnu takistada.
Võibolla eelmise sajandi alguse mustvalgetes komöödiates, aga Charlie Chaplin tõepoolest ei ole autoriteet inimese loomuliku käitumise suhtes.
Prille kandev inimene ei tarvitse otsuse langetamisel lõuga silitada, selle asemel võtab ta prillid eest ning pistab sangaotsa endale suhu.
Jällegi, tegevused mida võib näha müügikonsultantide koosolekul ei ole hea indikaator loomulikust käitumisest.
Ristates käed rinnale, tekitame tõkke. Kui kuulaja nõnda käitub, siis tähendab see tema eitavat seisukohta ning tähelepanu hajumist. Sellist poosi sunnib võtma tema sisemine pingeseisund ja vastuolu. Et sellise inimese suhtumist muuta, tuleks tema käed ristiasendist lahti harutada. Talle võib näiteks ulatada mingisuguse eseme. Nõnda asub kuulaja avatumasse poosi ning ka tema suhtumine muutub.
Klassikaline Pease, aga äärmiselt kummaline. Meenub The Simpsonitest moment mil Homer üritab Marge'i ristatud käsi vägisi lahti harutada, edutult. Ja huvitav kui palju eestlasi ongi sellise soovituse ajendil ristatud kätega isikutele midagi hoida ulatanud ja siis seeläbi ebamugavat olukorda veel ebamugavamaks muutnud.
Oma sõjakust väljendame käsi puusa pannes. Selle poosi võtab sisse inimene, kes on valmis oma eesmärke saavutama.
Meenuvad pildid koolikiusamisest millel ohver on maas põlvili, üks kiusaja peksab ja teised seisavad ümber käsi puusas.
Eks iga inimene ole kord soovinud endale võimet teiste mõtteid lugeda. Seda iha on peetud müstiliseks. Tegelikult on see aga võimalik – kehakeele abil. Selleks, et mõista inimeste käitumist, peame õppima mõistma nende kehakeelt, millega on tihtipeale väga raske oma mõtteid saladuses hoida, kuna vastavad žestid ja poosid on meile harjumuseks saanud. Lugenud läbi käesoleva referaadi, oskate paremini mõista inimese mõtteid.
Nõup. Mitte mõtteid kui selliseid. Käežestid võivad verbaalset informatsiooni täiendada ning seeläbi mingeid mõttemustreid ära tunda... Aga üldiselt aitab kehakeele jälgimine aimata - nagu teksti alguses on tegelikult selgelt öeldud - meeleolu, seisundit või suhtumist. Ehk siis (gross) mood, emotion and attitude. Sellele tekstile annan hindeks kolme.


PealkiriMillest räägib mehe kehakeel? - Suhted & seks - naine24.ee
Linkhttp://www.naine24.ee/804622/millest-raagib-mehe-kehakeel/
Lühiväljavõte11 apr. 2012 – Osa teabest edastame me pigem kehakeele abil kui sõnadega. Seetõttu vaata ja jälgi teda ja sa või...

Veebileht Datingtipps.at paljastas mõned olulisemad märgid, kuidas mõista flirtiva mehe kehakeelt.
Okei, ma natuke loodan, et kuna allikas on mingisugune saksakeelne sait siis siin on midagi mida ma veel ei pruugi teada.
Ta naeratab sulle.
Ja see on märk, et mees flirdib sinuga? Brilliant.
Ta pingutab oma lihaseid, et demonstreerida oma lihaste jõudu ja näidata kaitsevõimet.
Yes, wooing women with le muscles. ofc
Ta üritab saada sinuga silmsidet ja hoiab seda kauem kui sina.
See on isegi huvitav, sest kauem silmsidet hoidev osapool justkui "domineerib". Niiet selle juhendi järgi on see hea kui mees domineerib.
Ta kallutab oma ülakeha sinu poole.
Sellest ma ei saa aru. Millises olukorras on see normaalne, et ülakeha kallutatakse naisterahva poole?
Ta puudutab ennast (manipuleerib), näiteks kohendab juukseid, hõõrub nimetissõrmega kergelt oma ninasõõrmeid, mängib lipsuga. Sellised füüsilised liigutused on märgid sellest, et tal on läheduse vajadus.
Haha, lol. Ninasõõrmete hõõrumine nimetissõrmega on üldiselt märk ebamugavusest. Siinne soovitus naistele on tõlgendada seda kui lähedusvajadust ja muuta ebamugav olukord... seksikalt ebamugavaks.
Ta pöörab oma pea järsult sinu poole, kui sa naeratad.
Hmm... Tahaks isegi lugeda seda uurimistööd mis selle välja selgitas.
Signaalid, mis annavad märku: «Hoia eemale!»
• Ta väldib sinuga silmsidet.
• Tema pilk on suunatud kellelegi teisele.
• Tema kehahoiak on suletud või sinust eemale suunatud. Näiteks ta hoiab oma käsi risti rinna peal või keerab oma pea vestluse ajal mujale.
• Ta on lodevas asendis ja laseb näiteks kõhul vabalt välja rippuda.
Huvitav, et mille kohta mina ütleksin lihtsalt "Ta ei ole huvitatud", on siin käskivalt "Hoia eemale!" Run, bitch, run! Selle nimekirja tõlkinud naisterahvas nimetab end "reporteriks" ja ütleb, et ta "toimetas". Küll on uhked tiitlid tõlkimistegevusele. Kolm inimest on FB-s seda artiklit laikinud ja see ei ole pälvinud mitte ühtegi kommentaari. Muuseas, ka pealkiri on väär, sest selle küsimusele ei esitata vastust. Seda muidugi juhul kui kõik millest meeste kehakeel räägib ongi ainult kahetine: sümpaatia ja "Hoia eemale!" Hindeks annan kahe.


PealkiriBuduaar - Frederico: Kehakeel ehk armastuse märgid
Linkhttp://buduaar.ee/Article/article/frederico-kehakeel-ehk-armastuse-margid
Lühiväljavõte7 aug. 2009 – Frederico: Kehakeel ehk armastuse märgid. Pilt: Sxc. Miks selline teema päevakorral on? Sest ma olen korduvalt täheldanud erinevaid märke ...

Juba ette aiman ära, et siit tuleb veel mingit jama. Kehakeel EHK armastuse märgid? Kas mitteverbaalselt väljendatakse AINULT armastust? "Suhted ja seks" rubriigis võibolla tõesti.
Kuid kahjuks on tihtipeale nii, et mees kas ei näe või teeb sellise näo, et ei näe, või lihtsalt muutub häbelikuks padakonnaks, kes ei saa aru, et temaga soovitakse suhelda. Ennekõike on see probleem tingitud sellest, et me elame Põhjamaal, meie mehed pole kuumaverelised italjaanod, kes kasvõi ühe naise poolt lendu saadetud naeratuse peale ta tähelepanuga jalust rabavad.
Hmm... Eesti mehed ei vasta igale seksuaalsignaalile suhtlemisalgatusega sest... 1) nad on häbelikud, 2) ei saa aru, 3) nad on külmaverelised (wtf), 4) nad ei raba naisi tähelepanuga. Kuidas sellised vastuväited sobiksid: 1) häbelikkus ei pruugi olla sisemine atribuut vaid olukord ise tekitab võimaluse kergesti häbisse sattuda, 2) kui me püüaksime iga kehalise signaali kinni mida inimesed välja saadavad tahtmatult, siis ei suudaks me üldse ühiskonnas toimida, 3) vere temperatuurist ei saa ma aru, ei oska ka midagi vastata, 4) meie kultuuriruumis ei ole viisakas nt tänaval ilusate tüdrukute suunas ilusaid sõnu karjuda ja selline tähelepanu nagu siin silmas peetakse võib ilmneda kui ahistamine.
Enne seda, kui räägin teile üksikasjalikult oma huvitavamatest seiklustest selles vallas ja käin välja omapoolse teooria, soovin ära märkida ühe äärmiselt huvitava raamatu nimega „Armastuse märgid“, mille autor on filosoofiadoktor David Givens. See raamat avas mu silmad paljudes huvitavates küsimustes. Raamatu autor on uurinud väga üksikasjalikult mehe ja naise käitumist erinevates olukordades, mis puudutavad kurameerimist vastassugupoolega. Raamatus tulevad vaatluse alla sõnatud märgid, signaalid ja liigutused, mida inimesed kasutavad, et kaaslast kütkestada, endale hoida ja võita. Fakt on ka see, et kehakeelt valdasid inimesed juba miljoneid aastaid tagasi, enne seda, kui ei osatud veel tänapäevaselt suhelda.
"Tänapäevaselt suhtlemine" kõlab ulmeliselt. Givens on anthropoloogilise haridusega, mitte "filosoof". Tema Armastuse märgid ei ole kokkuvõte tema üksikasjalikust mehe ja naise käitumise uurimisest. Givens tegi seda mida enamus autoreid kes raamatu kaanele panevad oma nime järele "Ph.D" - sünteesis teisi populaarteaduslikke raamatuid ja kirjutas juurde seda mida aknast nägi.
Seda raamatut lugedes saab selgeks, kui palju tagamõtteid, tundeid ja hirme paljastab meie keha sõnatu keel. Arvatakse, et 60 kuni 93 protsenti inimese suhtlusest põhineb sõnadeta väljendataval osal. Intiimsuhetes toimub üle 99 protsendi emotsionaalsest suhtluselt sõnatult. Emotsioonide puhul inimesed mitte ei kõnele oma tunnetest, vaid lasevad oma kehal rääkida.
Valed. Protsendid ei pea kunagi paika, veel enam kui "arvatakse", et nii ja nii palju protsente - protsente ei arvata! Tule mõistus koju, arvamused esitatakse sõnades, protsendid on kvantitatiivsete mõõtmistulemuste esitamiseks. Ja ma tahaks teada kuidas see 99 protsenti emotsionaalsest suhtlemisest paika peab kui igal sammul küsime üksteiselt "Mis sul viga on?" ja tihti ei saa ühest vastust, sest emotsioone on raske kirjeldada. Mõni ütleb vastupidi, et emotsioonidest tuleb kõneleda ja ühises keeles. Ainus viis see natukenegi senssi meikib on see, et Frederico ei saanud päris täpselt aru mida Givens silmas peas kui väitis, et armatsedes kasutame peaaegu eranditult ainult kehakeelt, aga otsustas ikkagi midagi "sarnast" oma artiklis öelda.
Raamatu autor usub, et nende etappidega ei tohi kiirustada ja igal etapil on oma aeg.
Eksid jälle. Desmond Morris uskus, et etappidel on kindel (12-sammuline) järjestus ja tähtis on iga etapi läbimine, mitte ilmtingimata etappide kestus. Morrise tõlgendamine ei ole teadus. Ülejäänud artikkel seisneb Frederico heietusest kuidas ta ise ei ole suutnud naistele läheneda. Hinne: üks. Artikliga kaasneval pildil võiks olla see kiisu kes paneb käpa käe peale ja ütleb: "It's time to stop posting."
[lucy 09-08-2009 00:12] Ma pole kunagi oma elus mingeid märke lugenud või kehakeelt mõistatama pidanud, ometigi leidsin oma armastuse. Paljud inimesed mõtlevad lihtsalt liiga palju ja hakkavad otsima midagi, mida pole vaja, sest kõik on niigi iseenesestmõistetav. Seega sinu tekstil, Frederico, ei näe ma väga erilist mõtet. See pole aga solvang, vaid minu arvamus. Võiksid suunata oma energia mujale, õigele poole, kui nii väga endale naist otsid.
Kõige kainem ja asjalikum kommentaar nende 49 hulgast mida see artikkel on pälvinud. Ma ei nõustu ainult selle väitega, et lucy "pole kunagi oma elus mingeid märke lugenud või kehakeelt mõistatama pidanud", sest märkide tõlgendamine ja kehakeele mõistmine (vb mitte "mõistatamine") on paratamatu.


PealkiriTeadvusehuvi: Kehakeel, valetamine ja näitlemine
Linkhttp://teadvusehuvi.blogspot.com/2010/07/kehakeel-valetamine-ja-naitlemine.html
Lühiväljavõte5 juuli 2010 – Kehakeel Kehakeele ja emotsioonide juures arvestada emotsioonide väsimisega. Näiteks kui tund aega on mõni lõbusa olekuga naernud ...

Teadvusehuvi on üks asisemaid blogisid mida eestlane on üldse pidanud. Ma võin ainult oletada, et Tartu tudeng Märt kes Teadvusehuvi pidas on multitalentne neuroloogiatudeng. Nii palju kui ma olen Teadvusehuvi ka kaugelt imetlenud, ei ole ma seni tõepoolest ühtegi postitust suutnud lugeda - isegi mitte käesolevat mis kõneleb kehakeelest. Olen aus, neuroloogiliste terminite Eesti keelde tõlkimine on küll tänuväärne, aga asjatundmatule ikkagi mõistmatu. Kiire ülevaade ütleb aga, et siin väga neuroteaduslikke termineid ei olegi niiet asun hea meelega nüüd lugema.
Teadvuse uurimisel on üheks ilmselt kasulikuks oskuseks võime teisi mõista. Kehakeele tundmine võimaldab näha närvisüsteemi eri osade aktiivsust ning teha nendest järeldusi isegi kui teine ei oska või julge ennast väljendada. Näiteks olukordades, kus aetakse emotsioone reaalsusega sassi või püütakse elada standardite/normide/traditsioonide järgi, mida pole bioloogiliste taluvuspiiride tõttu võimalik kaua järgida. Enesepettuseid saaks ka omaette valetamise vormiks pidada.
Erinevalt eelnevatest lehekülgedes mis sisaldasid põhiliselt väiteid millega ei saa nõus olla, siis siin on Märt kohe alguses right on the money: 1) närvisüsteemi "erutusi" (excitement) on kõige ilmsel jälgida kehakeeles (Navarro ja teised ütleksid, et peaksime jälgima mugavust ja ebamugavust, aga närvisüsteem ilmselgelt sellega ei piirdu); 2) emotsioonide ja reaalsuse sassiajamine on pertinent: tõlgendaja närviseisund on samamoodi tähtis, sest võib piirata seda mis nö pääseb läbi filtri; 3) enesepettus ehk self-deception on sotsiaapsühholoogilise mina-kontseptsiooni juures tähtis; olgugi, et pettuseteooriad millega mina tuttav olen ei ole sellega väga tegelenud (peaksin sellesse rohkem süvenema, sest mulle meeldivad igasugused erinevad self-communication'i vormid).
Kehakeele ja emotsioonide juures arvestada emotsioonide väsimisega. Näiteks kui tund aega on mõni lõbusa olekuga naernud sama tugevuse ja sagedusega, on see tõenäoliselt sunnitud. Sunnitud naeru ja teiste emotsioonide korral on vähemad näolihased aktiivsed. Näiteks loomuliku naeratuse korral lähevad silmad veidi pilukile, kuid pikaajalise sunnitud naeratuse korral jäävad silma ümbruse lihased jälle lõdvemaks. Emotsioonide möödumistempot ning nendega kaasnevaid sümptomeid saab lihtsalt uurida enda peal eeldusel, et on varem ära õpitud emotsioonide esile kutsumine.
See on üks viise kuidas tuvastada teeseldud (või "sotsiaalset") naeratust: siiras naeratus tuleb esile progressiivselt ja vaibub loomulikul kombel. Ebasiira naeratuse iseloom on sunnituses - tekib järsku ja "väsib" ebakorrapäraselt (nt silmade ümbrus ja kulnud võtavad õige emotsiooni kuju, aga suu irvitab edasi). Kummaline, et nii palju kui ma emotsioonidest ja nendega seotud näoilmetest ka tean ei ole ma ikka veel võtnud kätte ja ära õppinud emotsioone esile kutsuma ning näolihaseid treenima. Seda viimast aspekti taipasin alles hiljuti - näolihased on lihased nagu lihased ikka - neid tuleb ka treenida, venitada, pingutada jne. Meelespea endale: otsi näolihaste treenimise kohta infot!
Noradrenaliini vabanemine vähendab raskus- ja väsimustunnet kehas ning tekitab jõulisemat poosi. Hirmu ja teiste tugevamalt ebameeldivate tunnete korral väheneb nihelemine (atsetüülkoliin inhibeerib striaatiumis dopamiini toimet).
Siin seisneb Märdi oluline panus: selliseid termineid näib olevat väga raske Eesti keelde tõlkida. Pean meeles nende ainete kohta rohkem uurida.
Punastamine näitab palavustunnet või osade intentsiivsemate emotsioonide olemasolud. Näiteks viha, kurbus, esinemisärevus, seksuaalne erutus, naer või häbi. Hirmu korral võib ka kahvatuks minna, sest adrenaliin kitsendab nahalähedasi veresooni. Olukorra järgi peaks enamasti kergesti aru saama mis põhjusel naha toon muutub.
Punastamine on üks nendest aspektidest mida täheldas ja arutas juba Charles Darwin. Adrenaliini veresooni kitsendavast mõjust ei olnud ma teadlik.
Püsti seistes võib pea liikumisest näha pulssi. See võib ilmsem olla lõdvema poosi korral ning kui süda hakkab jõulisemalt tööle ärevuse või elevuse korral.
Ka ei teadnud. Mingid ebausaldusväärsed allikad soovitavad interaktsioonis sünkroonsuse saavutamiseks teadlikult jälgida vestluspartneri õlgade üles-alla liikumist, et siis oma hingamisrütmi samaajastada (sünkroniseerida). Pealiikumisest pulssi järeldada näib ka pisut raske, sest selle jaoks peab erakordselt tähelepanelik olema. Lie To Me-s tehti seda nii, et peategelane jälgis uuritava kaelaveresoonte tukslemist ja arvutas käekellaga pulsi kiirenemist. Selleks peab muidugi väga võimekas olema.
Ärevuse korral kiireneb pilgutamine, keha jääb jäigemaks ka ebameeldivas poosis püsides ja higi saab stressile omase tugevama lõhna. Samuti tekib vajadus sagedamini juua, mis vähendab katseloomadel tehtud vaatlustes noradrenaliini vabanemist. Kui joogid on saadaval siis võib sellist käitumist paista neil, kes ennast ebamugavalt tunnevad.
Silmade pilgutamise kohta on minu teada ikka päris palju uurimusi tehtud (meenub üks mis isegi uuris silmapilgutuste ja rassismi seost). Keha jäigenemise kohta me ei tea - oletan, et sel on midagi pistmist lihastoonuse või närvisüsteemi erutusega? Higi lõhnade kohta öeldi aines "inimese keha kultuuriloos", et higil on päris mitu erinevat lõhnarežiimi sõltuvalt emotsionaalsest seisundist või tegevusest (ärevushigi on erinev sportimishigist). Noradrenaliini ja joomise seos seisneb dehüdraliseerumises? Märkasin ise, et võõraste inimeste seltskonnas Zawwis haarasin mina kõige tihemini joogi järele (teised tundsid üksteist, mina tundsin ainult ühte).
Vabalt tundes liigutakse rohkem, poose ei säilitata väga kaua ning käed on täenäolisemalt kehast kaugemal, kui ärevuse korral.
Selle kohta kirjutas antropoloog Edward T. Hall 1959. aastal tabavalt: "Frozen style is for people who are to remain strangers."
Atraktsiooni või lõbusa sõbralikkuse korral on rohkem nihelemist ja jõulisust meeldiva isiku märkamisel. Näost paistab unelevat rõõmu läbisegi ärevusega, mis võib tuleneda võib-olla lihtsalt kahtlustest, kas sellest saab midagi enamat.
Sõnastus on küll pisut populistlik, aga tähelepanek ise näib täitsa õige. Kogemus ütleb, et juhututtavaid kohates peab pingutama, et neile naeratada või kätt tõsta; aga kui vastu tuleb meeldiv sõber-tuttav "vanadest aegadest" siis nägu kisub tahtmatult naerule ja keha läbib "energiahoog" (mul pole paremat sõna selle jaoks).
Sümptomeid, mis alati valedega või ainult tõega kaasnevad, pole leitud.
Tõsi. See ei tähenda muidugi, et otsingud usaldusväärse valetamismärgi järele lakkaksid.
Ekman on uurinud ka nn. mikroekspressioone, mille puhul näoilmest paistab korraks läbi mõni teine näoilme ning need võivad näidata samaaegselt kogetud kuid rohkem varjatud emotsioone. Näoilme lühiajalisel muutusel võib põhjuseks olla ka mõttekäigus meenunud emotsioone tekitav mälestus, mis teeb nende kasutamise ebausaldusväärseks, kuid olukorda arvestades võib see midagi anda.
Olen ise olnud hädas kuidas seda sõna tõlkida. Mõnikord on see "mikromiimika" - kõlab hästi, aga "miimika" on kahtlustäratav sõna (selle täpne tähendus on mulle tundmatu); mõnikord aga "mikroväljendused" - keeleliselt korrektne, aga umbmäärasuse maiguga. Päris eestindades võib välja mõelda ka muid variante: "viivuväljendused" - keegi pole seda nii kasutanud, aga see kõlab täishäälikute tõttu sujuvalt; või kui täitsa leiutama hakata, siis "hetkeilmed" - õige selles mõttes, et need on näoilmed mis kestavad vaid hetke. Mingis mõttes kõlavad need variandid nagu "hetkeilme" oleks täielikult moodustunud näoilme mis kestab hetke ja "viivuväljendus" üksikute lihaste tõmblus mis ei kujune päris täielikult hetkeilmeks. Kui keegi kunagi hakkab Paul Ekmani raamatuid Eesti keelde tõlkima siis võiks neid variante vähemasti kaaluda.
Valetamisel võib vahele jäämise eest kaitsta vale sellises kohas, kus teine ei oska seda oodata või jääb liiga suurte kahtlustega.
Esimene osa tundub arusaadav - kui teine ootab sinult tõde, siis kahtlustab ta valet. Kui vestlus on aga neutraalne ja tõeküsitavus ei kerki üles siis võib valetada nii, et suu suitseb. Liiga suurte kahtluste osast aga ei saa ma hästi aru.
Ettevaatlikuks teeb mind kui näen jäiga enesekontrolliga tegelasi, kes suudavad ka vahelesegamisel jäiga (teeseldud?) rahuga jätkata. Nende keha näitab minimaalselt välja ning kergesti segatakse vahele neile ebameeldiva jutu ajamisel. Unepealt öeldakse vabandusi välja ja püütakse jutuga edasi minna, et teistel ei jääks järele mõtlemiseks aega.
Sellises olukorras peakski olema ettevaatlik, sest siis ei ole tegu mitte dialoogi või vahetusega, vaid see tegelane peab monoloogi milles ei ole enam tarvidust midagi muuta või üle mõelda - see on lõplik tõde ja midagi muud ei saagi olla. Samas vastupidine - minu juhtum - ei ole ka väga hea, sest kui keegi midagi vahele ütleb, siis kaldub see saama osa minu enda kõnest. Nii juhtub tihtipeale loengutes, et kui loengu alguses juhtun õppejõu käest mingi ähmasena näiva asja kohta selgitust küsima, siis juhul kui neil on endal ka ähmane selgitus võib juhtuda, et kogu ülejäänud loeng tegelevad nad tavapärast materjali ette kandes selle sama küsimusega. Tähendab, vahelesekkumine - interferents - on kogu nende kõne ümber kodeerinud ja võib juhtuda, et ülejäänud loeng pole enam niiväga arusaadav, sest õppejõud on selle ühe küsimusega vaevatud. See on põhjus miks loengute puhul tasub jätta küsimused viimaseks asjaks. Igapäevavestlustes aga peakski toimuma üksteise kõnede ümberkodeerimine - ühesõnaga, vahetus. Muidu ei sünni sellest midagi uut vaid jäiga enesekontrolliga tegelane annab sulle informatsiooni mis taotleb loengu-tõe staatust alusetult.
Ainuke moodus, millega ma ise suutsin naeru ja teisi emotsioone (kurbust, viha, elevust, häbi, ärevust, hirmu jne.) soovi korral esile kutsuda oli enesekontrolli all mainitud korduva meenutamisega. Esmalt peab oskama soovitud emotsiooni või seda tekitavat tunnet selgelt meenutada. Meenutamine mõjutab emotsioone ja selgelt uuesti meenutades see effekt kuhjub. Kui mõnu või naerueelset tunnet kiiresti meenutada (ise oskan kuni ~2-3 korda sekundis) võib sekunditega väga hea tuju saada.
Jah, see näib efektiivne, aga eeldab ka põhjalikku ettevalmistust. Minu hirm on, et kui emotsionaalsete mälestuste kinnistamist sellisel kombel harjutada, siis võib see kinnistamine olla liiga võimas. Tahan ma elu lõpuni mäletada neid emotsioone? Püsimälu tekitab minus aukartust.
Valetamine ei ole vajalik, kui tõde suudetakse vastuvõetavalt (usutavalt ja/või sümpaatselt) väljendada. See võib toimida juhul, kui seni on vastava omaduse puhul avalikkuses harjutud avaldama peamiselt kriitilist suhtumist ning mida vähem konkreetset või usutavat suudavad kriitikud välja tuua seda lihtsam peaks see olema. Sellist julgemat ausust tuleb harjutada, sest näiteks juba poliitikas ja skandaale kuulutavas meediaväljaandes esineb rutiinselt katseid konkurentide/teisitimõtlejate ideedele skandaalseid seoseid külge saada.
Jap, see on minu tehnika. Ma valetan väga vähe, sest lihtsam on tõde esitada vastuvõetaval kombel. Siirust ei pea teesklema, see ei vaja nii palju pingutamist. Ainult, et poliitikasse või meediasse minusugune ei kõlbaks, sest nendes valdkondades on valetamine ainus viis kuidas pinnal püsida.
Kuna paljud pole teaduses toimuvat realistllikult ära õppida saab õpetada veidi reaalselt toimivaid soovitusi, mida võib kombineerida teadusest pärinevate sõnade suvalise kasutamisega. Kergeusklik võib saada aru elulisest kasulikke soovitusest ning oletada, et segaseks jäänud teaduslike terminite segus on ka midagi sisukat.
Täpselt see kriitika mida osutan nö "postmodernsele teadusele": sellised autorid (eriti kirjanduskriitikud nagu Pechey või Blau) žongleerivad teaduslikult kõlavate terminitega, aga kasutavad neid suvaliselt; jätavad mulje, et nad ütlevad midagi mis peaks meikima senssi, aga ei meiki üldse - point on rohkem "teaduslikkuse tunde" tekitamine, keelemängu kaudu lugejale tarkuse fiiling anda. Kui selliseid tekste kriitiliselt lugeda võib hulluks minna.
Vaidlusest mitte aru saavad pealiskaudsed kõrvalvaatajad võivad paremini suhtuda sellesse, kes emotsioone paremini kontrollib ning selle ära kasutamiseks saab kergelt agressiivse solvamise või absurdse kriitika kasutamisel jutukaaslase vihaseks ajada.
Meenub ütlus filmist Thank You For Smoking: ma ei pea veenma sind [kellega ma väitlen], vaid neid [kes vaatavad pealt]. See artikkel kaldus väga tugevasti valetamis- ja mõjutamisdiskursusesse, aga kokkuvõttes väga hea. Hinne: viis!


PealkiriKehakeel reedab, kas teie suhtel on tulevikku | Õhtuleht
Linkhttp://www.ohtuleht.ee/211647
Lühiväljavõte29 nov. 2006 – Ninadega nahistamine, kallima teksade tagataskus puhkav käsi, sagedased kallistused – need on kindlad märgid, et paarikese armuasjad ...

Kohe esmapilgul jätab see artikkel tagurdlase mulje. Umbes nagu "mu käsi on ta pepu peale - OO! - ta vist meeldib mulle!". Kuna see on ikkagi Õhtuleht, siis I'll give it the benefit of the doubt ja loen selle ikkagi läbi.
Tracey Cox (born 1961) is a British non fiction author who specializes in books on dating, sex and relationships. She is the author of many best selling titles.
Kuna artikkel alustab sellest, et nimetab "seksieksperti" Tracey Cox, vaevusin kontrollima wikipediat. Seksiekspert võibolla tõesti, vähemasti on mingisugune psühholoogia-haridus olemas. Austraalia Cosmopolitani toimetanud, inimeste magamistubades kaameratega nende seksielu analüüsinud... mmm... I don't know man, kisub aimeliseks.
Mida lähemal on õrnutsedes alakõhud teineteisele, seda suurem on paari seksuaalne rahuldatus. Kui kokku puutuvad ka rindkered, on suhe lausa õnnelik. Hoiavad aga ülakehad armatsedes eemale, võib järeldada, et südamega asja juures ei olda.
Okei, mehhaaniliselt tundub see keeruline: täiuslik seks on siis üksteise peal lamamine, mis välistab päris paljud ägedad poosid.
Kui tema käsi on vajutatud sinu südame kohale, on see märk tundeaususest. Kui kuulsad Hollywoodi paarid tahavad kinnitada oma vahekorra ehtsust, kasutavad nad just seda sümboolikat.
Jällegi, see eeldab, et partnerite kehad on piisavalt vormis, et mehel pole nt manboobs'e. Jääb mulje, et täiuslik suhe eeldab täiuslikke kehasid. Sama kriitika mida ühe eelneva artikli suhtes sai kasutatud: Hollywood ei ole usaldusväärne allikas inimese loomuliku käitumise suhtes.
Käest kinni hoidmisel ei puutu teie kehad kokku, kuid jalutades kaaslast piha ümbert kallistades võite end teineteise vastu suruda. Veelgi tähendusrikkam on asend, kus partneril hoitakse ümbert kinni sõrmseongus kätega. Nii on kallike võimalikult lähedal. Partner annab märku, et ta ei taha sind lahti lasta ning kaitseb sind kõige kurja eest.
Veel kord: romantiline, aga mitte-praktiline.
Kehvas seksisuhtes kaovad kallistused tavaliselt esimesena. Kui soovite suhet päästa, pugege teineteisele kaissu. Kallistamisel vallanduv oksü­tot­siin on hormoon, mis tekitab lähedustunnet ja seksiisu.
Vähemasti see tundub olevat usaldusväärne indeks, et kallistamine väheneb suhte jahenedes. Nimekiri "Suhtel on tulevikku" märkidest:
  • Te suudlete nagu eskimod
  • Partner surub puusad sinu puusade vastu
  • Laubad puutuvad kokku
  • Partner pöördub kõndides sinu poole
  • Partner paneb peopesa vastu sinu rinda
  • Partner paneb käe sinu alakõhule
  • Partner paneb käe sinu tagumikule
  • Partner hoiab kinni su pihast, mitte käest
  • Te kallistate soojalt ja sageli
Labajalgade asend on oivaline viide suhte tulevikule. Kui seisad partneriga koos, kuid tema varbad piiluvad eemale, loodab ta võimalikult kähku sinu juurest vehkat teha.
Ma tean, et labajalgade suund näib olevat usaldusväärne indeks, sest nagu Navarro väidab, me pöörame rohkem tähelepanu peale ja kätele ning vähem tähelepanu sellele mida meie kehad teevad allpool vööd... Aga igas olukorras ei tasu ikka labajalgade suunda võtta kui suhtestaatuse märki.
Eriti valvas tasub olla siis, kui kallim sügab kõrva, väldib silmsidet või ei puuduta sind. Kõrvasügaja ei taha end valetamas kuulda. Teisele otsa vaadates on väga raske valetada. Ja peaaegu võimatu on see vestluskaaslast puudutades.
Veel tinglikuid asju. Esiteks on "Kõrvasügaja ei taha end valetamas kuulda" liiga Pease. Teiseks pidavat lugu olema hoopis selline, et valetades vaatame rohkem silma, et jälgida seda kuidas valet vastu võetakse. Ja kolmandaks võib vabalt arvata, et parimad valetajad kasutavad puudutamist teadlikult usaldustunde tekitamiseks. Nimekiri "Suhe on hääbumas" märkidest:
  • Partneri varbad on suunatud sinust eemale
  • Seisate teineteisest lahus
  • Ta kallistab sind kõrgelt või kaela ümbert
  • Te kõnnite eri tempos
  • Oled veendunud, et partner ei peta sind iialgi
Kõiki neid märke võib veel lõputult kritiseerida, aga suhteasjad tõepoolest ei ole minu ekspertiis niiet seda oleks vara teha. Kokkuvõttes palju ilmselgeid (obvious) tähelepanekuid millega võib ja võib mitte nõustuda, vahet eriti pole. Vähemasti ei olnud midagi liiga väära. Hinne: neli.
[Ef, 09:15, 29. november 2006] Ei ole midagi erilist. Ammu teada faktid
Kohe esimene kommentaar kuuest ütleb täpselt seda mida mina arvan.
[täitsa lõpp lugu, 20:03, 29. november 2006] ma pole oma vanavanemaid kunagi selliselt üksteise küljes rippumas näinud, aga ikkagi on nad 50+ aastat koos olnud. samas näen ma pidevalt kuidas noored üksteise küljes ripuvad, aga täna ripub ta ühes taskus, homme teises. täna hoiab ühe kõhtu ja tissi, homme aga teise kõhtu ja tissi, ning ülehomme on juba kaks esimest unustatud... kas ikka on see suhte tunnus?
See kommenteerija laksas ka biiti, et Tracey Cox-i kujutatud täiuslik suhe on sisuliselt värske armumise kiimlus. Tegelikud suhted, veel enam pikaajalised, ei ole sellised: mingil hetkel muutub üksteise küljes rippumine vanaks ja hakatakse oma ruumi otsima ning aktsepteeritavaid piire seadma.


PealkiriKehakeel
Linkhttp://www.hkhk.edu.ee/vanker/suhtlemine2/kehakeel.html
LühiväljavõteSõnaline e. verbaalne suhtlemine moodustab vaid osa meie igapäevasest suhtlemisest. Teine osa, mis ei ole sugugi vähemoluline suhtlemisel, ...

Siin näib olevat mingisugune [Haapsalu Kutsehariduskeskuse] õpilaste koostatud koduleht suhtlemisest. Nad on isegi teinud endist pilte ja riputanud siia üles. Viivuks mõtlesin, et riputan siia illustreerivaks pildiks mõne neist, aga see võib jällegi neid mingil kombel solvata.
Sissejuhatus ütleb, et "Õppematerjal on loodud suhtlemispsühholoogia tunni rikastamiseks ja mitmekülgsemaks muutmiseks." Keelekasutus juba annab aimu, et põhjuks miks nad "rikastavad" ja "muudavad mitmekülgsemaks" on kuidagi seotud Euroopa Liidu Sotsiaalfondi ja "Eesti tuleviku heaks" logodega mis on ühel nende lehekülgedest. Kasutatud kirjanduse hulgas on kuus eestikeelset tõlget:
  • Bolton, R. Igapäevaoskused 2006
  • Goleman, D. Sotsiaalne intelligentsus 2007
  • Kidron, A. Suhtlemine 2004
  • McKay, M.; Davis,M.; Fanning, P. Suhtlemisoskused 2004
  • Navarro, J. Kehakeelest 2010
  • White, V.; Demarais, A. Esmamuljed 2005
Mul on küll tunne, et käesoleval aastakümnel oleks juba hädasti vaja mõne eestlase kirjutatud suhtlemisõpikut. Oma kutsekooli kirjandusõpetaja kujul on mul ehk tutvus olemas, et kunagi see nali ära teha ja korraliku kirjaduse kaudu avaldada. Selle jaoks pole ma praegu veel valmis, aga varsti juba pruugin olla.
Selle õpiobjekti menüüs on järgnevad alateemad: Esmamulje, Enesetutvustus, Kehakeel, Erinevad Käitumisstiilid. Mind huvitab praegu ainult see mida nad kujutavad kehakeelena.
Mitteverbaalse suhtluse võib jagada kaheks:
  • Liigutused: näoilme, žestid, kehahoiak
  • Ruumisuhted: kui kaugele te vestluspartnerist hoiate.
Noh, ma tahtsin teada mis on nende arusaam. Ma ei saa neile pahaks panna, et nende arusaam on väga piiratud (aluseks oleva kirjanduse põhjal ma ei imesta). Lühidalt, siin eristatakse ainult kineesikat ja prokseemikat. Jääb isegi mulje, et kehahoiaku ja kehadevahelise kauguse vahel on ületamatu kuristik kuhu keha ringiliikumine (locomotion) on sisse kukkunud. Niisama naljaviluks võin taaskord rivistada nii palju muid alavaldkondi kui praegu pähe hüppab: haptika (puudutamine), taktileesika (kokkupuudete tundmine), okuleesika (vaatamine), kroneemika (ajakasutus), koeneesika (sünkroonsus). Peaaegu soovin, et proprioseptsioonil oleks ka mingi foneetika-analoog, nt proprioneemika. Tõsiasjaks jääb ikkagi see, et need eemilised ja eetilised (Pike'i emic ja etic) klassid on justkui "surnud teadusharud" - nad hüüti välja, aga midagi põhjalikku nendega kunagi ei tehtud - kineesika ja prokseemikaga sama lugu, sest lihtsam on nimetada kogu kupatust mitteverbaalseks suhtlemiseks kuiet hakata meelevaldselt eristama mis kuulub ühe või teise alla. Ja parakeel on üldse ära unustatud - seda mainitakse alles Mehrabiani müüdi kordamisel ("vokaalne" mõju).
Nägu on inimese kõige väljendusrikkam kehaosa. Miimilised näolihased reageerivad väga kiiresti inimeses toimuvatele mõtlemisprotsessidele, tundevarjunditele ja emotsionaalsele seisundile.
Mind pisut huvitab kuidas nad eristavad miimilisi ja mittemiimilisi näolihaseid. Teatavasti Duchenne ja Darwin kes esimesena näo väljendusrikkust uurisid olid hädas, et lihaseid üldse näos eristada, sest nad on üksjagu kattuvad ja risti-rästi.
Avatud pihuga väljasirutatud käed viitavad siirusele. Kui samas asendis kehitatakse õlgu, öeldakse kehakeeles:"Kust mina pean seda teadma?" või "Ma ei saanud sinna midagi parata." Rinnal ristatud käsi tõlgendatakse kaitsepositsiooni või salatsemissooviga.
Tsau, Allan Pease! Your very obvious misinterpretations still keep on getting misinterpreted, good for you! Ülejäänud tekst siin ongi Pease'i kordamine. Teda ei ole küll kasutatud kirjanduse hulgas, aga tema jampsi on ilmselt korratud neis raamatutes mis on kasutatud kirjanduse hulgas. Üle kolme ma hindeks anda ei saa.



Ja ongi tulnud aeg kokku võtta mida google-otsingu "kehakeel" esimene lehekülg otsijale annab. Mitte palju, sugugi mitte palju. Põhiliselt lehekülgi mis kasutavad sõna "kehakeel" nii nagu jumal juhatab; kehva eeltöö teinud kokkuvõtteid kogu valdkonnast mis kordavad vaid seda mida keskmine Jüri niigi teab; ja uudislugusid naisteajakirjades mis üritavad kehakeele abil avada seksuaalsuse müsteeriumit, enamasti poolikult ja edutult. Teadvusehuvi artikkel kehakeelest on siin silmapaistev erand, sest see on ainus mis ei korda ühtegi müüti ega kližeed ja paljastab kehalise käitumise kohta midagi mida tõepoolest tuleb erialakirjandusest näpuga taga otsida. Kiitus Märdile ja julgustus, et ta tänavu aprillis pooleli jäetud blogi ikka edasi kirjutaks.

Kuna selle survey tegemine oli suhteliselt lõbus ja huvitav siis tõenäoliselt teen seda veel. Otsing "kehakeel" annab ikkagi 210 tuhat otsingutulemust niiet materjali millega tegeleda on sisuliselt lõputult. Usun, et kui piisavalt kaugele minna sellise tööga siis jõuaks kehakeele-ainelistest artiklitest ka selle juurde kuidas eestlased seda sõna oma igapäevastes internetipostitustes kasutavad ja mida nad sellest teavad.

Ja lõpetuseks uitmõte mis tekkis seda survey-d tehes. Nimelt: mis teeb inimesest kehakeele-eksperdi? Minu arvates piisab loetud raamatute hulga arvestamisest. Kui sa loed ühe raamatu - nagu Frederico tegi - ja kirjutad sellest kirjatüki, oled sa "poseerija" ja väärid kriitikat. Kui sa loed kümme raamatut siis oled sa juba "teadlik" - ise lugesin oma esimese kuuga 15 populaarteaduslikku raamatut läbi ja sain maitse suhu. Kui sa loed sada raamatut - mina olen selle blogi andmetel 77 juures - oled sa tõeline "huviline" ja sinu arvamust võib juba arvestada. Ja viimaks, kui sa oled lugenud tuhat raamatut, siis oled sa täieõiguslik asjatundja. With any kind of luck saab minust lähema dekaadi jooksul asjatundja ja internetis ringlevate pooltõdede kritiseerimise asemel konstrueerin eestlase jaoks Eesti keeles arusaadava pildi inimese kehalise käitumise mõistmisest.